6 Instances Where DnD Logic Makes No Sense

If you’re a diehard Dungeons & Dragons (DnD) fan, you’re probably used to hand-waving bizarre, head-scratching details. Sure, the game is enchanting, immersive, and endless fun, but let’s face it—not everything about DnD logic would fly in the real world. So here’s a fun “reality” check for those of us who’ve probably spent too many sessions arguing over spell mechanics in the middle of an encounter. It’s time to dig into why some aspects of DnD logic are riddled with cracks (but let’s be real, we love it for that).

The Economics of Adventuring Is Laughably Incoherent 

Ever stop to wonder how your Level 3 Wizard affords robes worth more than an actual house? Or better yet, how a low-tier novice manages to have the kind of gold reserves that would make a medieval king jealous? The DnD economy is clearly drunk. Seriously, you can loot a random bandit camp and somehow rake in enough wealth to retire five times over.

And don’t get me started on equipment prices. A single healing potion costs 50 gold pieces, which is the same as a not-too-shabby horse. Who’s deciding these exchange rates, exactly? Are we just ignoring inflation? Meanwhile, peasants are apparently surviving on a few silver pieces. Guess they’ve never shopped at the Adventurer Corner.

Break Your Leg? Just Take a Nap! 

Here’s a fun nugget for you. Break your leg IRL, and you’re stuck hobbling around on crutches for weeks. Break your leg in DnD and poof, it’s magically fine after a long rest. Nothing screams “fantasy immersion” like a party nap healing everything from critical head wounds to poison effects. Do Polysporin and ice packs not exist in this universe?

And for anyone out there shouting, “But that’s what magic is for!”… calm down, Brennan. Even in a magic-heavy world, I find it hilarious that sleeping on a bedroll entirely erases the fact that you had a sword sticking through your spleen an hour earlier. But hey, who wants to spend weeks in-game waiting for that spleen to heal? It’s Fantasy!

Why Are Rations Even a Thing? 

Alright, I HAVE to talk about rations. These are supposed to be critical supplies that your party must manage to avoid starvation, right? The logic is sound, but the thing is, most DMs either willingly ignore or completely forget to incorporate this survival mechanic into their campaigns.

You could throw a party into the desert, and most of the time, the DM only caring about who’s rolling high on survival checks. It’s like rations are the IKEA end-tables of DnD. Yeah, they’re there, but nobody’s really using them properly. However, it’s undeniably a residual feature of the OG rules. And so it stays, edition after edition.

Armor Logic Defies Everything We Know About Physics