Indiana Fever guard Sophie Cunningham had an eventful game in many ways in her return to PHX Arena on Thursday night — and fans could not help but notice that she paid the price.
The Fever got blown out 95-60 by her former WNBA team, the Phoenix Mercury.
Cunningham spent the first six seasons of her professional career in Phoenix, where she averaged 7.7 points, 2.7 rebounds and 1.4 assists over 182 games.
At some point in the second half, the punishment Cunningham took from her former teammates during the game became visible on her face. She got a souvenir to take back with her to Indianapolis under her right eye.
What happen to Sophie Cuningham? @IndianaFever @sophaller #Fevers #IndianaFever pic.twitter.com/BVyoL2ifzp
— Logan Jenkins (@LoganJe1966) August 8, 2025
"So Sophie's got a black eye??" asked an X user.
"Are the announcers just gonna ignore Sophie Cunningham's black eye??" said another.
"Indiana Fever’s Sophie Cunningham is a fighter," admired one fan. "Black eye, busted lip, still fighting."
Others wondered when and how and why it happened, but there was no clear incident that led to the mark on her eye.
She did have several scrappy moments with her former Mercury teammates, including forward DeWanna Bonner, who was waived by the Fever in June.
Things getting chippy out there after this Sophie/Bonner play pic.twitter.com/DUHse0nO1c
— AK (@Sudharsan_AK10) August 8, 2025
Cunningham made five three-pointers and led the Fever with 18 points on Thursday, but that is not all.
It was Indiana's second straight loss, dropping them to 17-14 on the season. They are 9-9 without Clark.
Thursday's defeat drops the Fever 2.5 games behind the Mercury (19-11) in the WNBA standings. They still have a 2-game cushion over the Golden State Valkyries (14-15) for the eighth and final playoff position.
Cunningham will have two days to heal up her eye before the Fever take on the Chicago Sky on Saturday at 8 p.m. ET on CBS.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!