Pat McAfee names college football QB who might be greatest freshman ever

It was a decision rooted in his composure, arm talent and ability to adapt quickly in practice. That trust paid off as he looked poised from start to finish, controlling the tempo and keeping mistakes to a minimum.

Beyond the numbers, Underwood’s presence has already given Michigan fans hope for another sustained run of national contention. Following last year’s national championship and quarterback turnover, the Wolverines needed a fresh face capable of handling the spotlight. Underwood, barely 18 years old, seems ready to embrace it.

How Underwood Compares To Past Freshman Greats

McAfee’s statement, while provocative, places Underwood alongside an elite group of freshmen who changed college football. Trevor Lawrence at Clemson led his team to a national title in 2018, while Oklahoma’s Adrian Peterson rushed for nearly 2,000 yards in 2004. More recently, Ohio State wideout Jeremiah Smith posted 1,300 yards and 15 touchdowns in 2024, while LSU’s Derek Stingley Jr. dominated defensively in 2019.

Underwood’s candidacy for “greatest freshman ever” is still just beginning, but his resume is already unique. No other freshman quarterback has debuted as both a record-setter and video game cover athlete before their first season ended. His path, if sustained, could put him in the same conversation as those who defined eras.

The Wolverines’ clash with Oklahoma marks Underwood’s first real test against ranked competition, an environment that has historically made or broken promising freshmen. If he continues to thrive, the comparisons to Lawrence or Peterson will only grow louder.

McAfee’s bold claim might have been part showmanship, but it also captured the reality of college football’s new moment: a teenager from Belleville, Michigan, has a chance to redefine what’s possible in a freshman season. Underwood’s story is only starting, but the spotlight will not dim anytime soon.

Read more on College Football HQ