Ty Simpson: From Bench to First-Round Pick

Ty Simpson’s Draft Profile

Ty Simpson needed just one season to prove his worth to NFL scouts. Though it took time for him to take over as Alabama’s QB1, he used his development period on the bench to refine his game and emerge as a polished, pro-ready prospect. Simpson has showcased quick decision-making at a high level throughout the season, along with the ability to create plays when the initial plan breaks down. He’s an athletic quarterback who can extend plays with his legs, making life difficult for pass rushers. But what truly sets Simpson apart as a prospect is his arm talent — a blend of impressive strength and pinpoint accuracy. He has the arm strength to make any throw on the field and has shown impressive accuracy in recent games, consistently posting high completion percentages and passer ratings.

First-Round Talent?

Short answer: yes. Ty Simpson has proven he’s a first-round talent, not just because of his raw ability, but because of what he’s accomplished for Alabama. However, Ty Simpson isn’t the QB1 or QB2 in this draft class; those roles belong to Fernando Mendoza and Dante Moore.

Fernando Mendoza projects as a more complete quarterback prospect than Ty Simpson. Mendoza shows greater poise in the pocket, superior accuracy, and a stronger arm. While Simpson holds the edge in athleticism, Mendoza’s passing talent gives him the overall advantage. Dante Moore, on the other hand, isn’t as refined as Simpson right now, but his ceiling is higher. Moore’s athleticism and accuracy stand out — and being two and a half years younger than Simpson makes his long-term potential even more intriguing.

Mendoza and Moore being considered better prospects than Ty Simpson isn’t a knock on the Alabama signal-caller. Simpson is a strong prospect with impressive traits — he might not be the top quarterback in his class, and that’s okay. When he finally gets his shot to start on an NFL roster, he’ll prove that those three years of patient development on the bench were well worth it.