Yardbarker
x

Will Sooner nation give Oklahoma head coach Brent Venables a pass with star quarterback John Mateer out? Venables entered 2025 already on the hot seat—now the No. 7 Sooners (4-0, 1-0 SEC) must prove it can compete without its starting quarterback.

Mateer injury

The Sooners’ season took a sharp turn with the news that their starting quarterback will miss significant time after undergoing hand surgery. For a program built on its proud tradition of quarterback play, the setback comes at an already tense moment. Venables entered this season with pressure mounting after back-to-back years that fell short of Oklahoma’s lofty standards. Now, the injury raises the question: will this misfortune ease the scrutiny or only heighten it?

Venables’ Hot Seat

Venables has faced criticism for failing to replicate the offensive firepower that defined the Sooners in the Lincoln Riley era. While his defenses have shown flashes of progress, Oklahoma’s offense has often lacked rhythm and consistency. That dynamic makes the quarterback’s absence all the more concerning, as the Sooners cannot afford to stumble through another mediocre campaign, especially with SEC play looming on the horizon. For Venables, how his team responds will be critical. If the offense looks stagnant and the Sooners slide into another disappointing season, few will give him a pass simply because of an injury. On the other hand, if the team competes hard, finds ways to win and shows growth under adversity, this setback could buy Venables some goodwill.

Oklahoma fans demand excellence and patience is wearing thin. A down year marked by excuses will not calm the pressure surrounding the program. Venables doesn’t need perfection this fall, but he does need a clear sign that the Sooners are building toward contention again.

Whether the quarterback injury becomes a fair “Mulligan” or just another reason to question the program’s direction will depend less on circumstance and more on how the Sooners fight through it. The Sooners have the Red River Rivalry gams against No.10 Texas (3-1) in two weeks. That will be a big test for the Sooners offense.

This article first appeared on Mike Farrell Sports and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!