Ferrari’s long-awaited homecoming at the Emilia Romagna Grand prix has quickly turned into a nightmare. Both Charles Leclerc and Lewis Hamilton failed to make it into Q3 during Saturday’s qualifying session at Imola, finishing 11th and 12th, respectively.
While the Scuderia stumbled in front of a sea of Tifosi, it was their former driver—Carlos Sainz—who stole the spotlight with a blistering lap.
Sainz, now racing for Williams after Ferrari replaced him with Hamilton for 2025, qualified a solid sixth. His performance left F1 journalist Peter Windsor questioning Ferrari’s judgement.
“This is perhaps the best proof that Ferrari made a mistake,” Windsor said in a YouTube analysis, “Sainz clocked the fastest time. This sums up everything that is wrong with Ferrari.”
Windsor didn’t mince words when assessing team boss Fred Vasseur’s decision-making.. “Vasseurs management at Ferrari should now really come under a magnifying glass,” Windsor said. “It’s one thing that the team chooses a big brand like Lewis Hamilton, but it’s quite another that the team boss allows this.”
Ferrari’s issues extended beyond driver choices. According to Windsor, the team failed to unlock pace from Friday to Saturday—while rivals Red Bull and Aston Martin gained nearly a full second. “Ferrari found only a tenth or two. That’s ridiculous,” he said. “This has to do with the choices the team makes on the circuit.”
Ready to give it everything today
— Scuderia Ferrari HP (@ScuderiaFerrari) May 18, 2025
A special ride-along with @LewisHamilton pic.twitter.com/i57yFmRe5J
Meanwhile, Aston Martin’s aggressive tire strategy paid off, landing both Lance Stroll and Fernando Alonso in Q3. Windsor credits the influence of Adrian Newey, who recently joined the team from Red Bull, as a potential catalyst for their sudden improvement.
With expectations sky-high and pressure mounting, Ferrari’s disappointing qualifying at Imola has reignited debate over its strategic direction—both on and off the track.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!