Why Does My Stud Finder Give False Readings?

Originally posted on Men's Journal | By Pete Fazio | Last updated Feb 8, 2025 10:45 AM ET

Have you ever tried to hang a heavy picture frame or mount a flat-screen TV, only to find that your stud finder doesn’t seem to work? It beeps randomly, shows inconsistent readings, or just plain leaves you scratching your head. This is a common problem, and it’s often due to a mix of how the device works, the type of wall you’re scanning, or user error.

How Do Stud Finders Work?

To troubleshoot your tool's inaccurate readings, it helps to understand how it works and the type of stud finder you're using. Most types fall into two categories: magnetic and electronic.

Magnetic stud finders work using a magnetic field to locate metal nails or drywall screws in studs by detecting metal. These are simple, don’t need batteries, and are very reliable—if the metal fastener is in the right spot.
Electronic stud finders measure changes in density inside your wall. As they scan, electronic sensors detect where a stud edge begins and ends based on the denser material and let you know with a beeping sound or lights.

Both types can give false readings. Magnetic options only work if nails or screws are present and in the right place, while electronic ones can get thrown off by factors like uneven drywall, lath and plaster walls, or even electrical wires. Understanding which type of stud finder you have can help explain the kind of errors you’re seeing.

Common Reasons Your Stud Finder Might Seem Broken

There are several reasons it might not give accurate readings. Most problems are caused by common mistakes and the tool being used incorrectly, or issues with the wall itself. Here are the most frequent culprits for inconsistent readings:

Irregular wall surfaces: Textured drywall, plaster, or paneling can interfere with readings, especially for electronic models.
User error: Moving the device too quickly or holding it at the wrong angle can confuse it. Always start scanning on a flat, steady surface and move slowly.
False positives: Electronic stud finders may beep due to wires, pipes, or uneven wall construction instead of finding a wooden stud.
Low battery power: A weak battery can affect the accuracy of electronic models. Replace it if the device feels inconsistent.
Incorrect calibration: Most electronic stud finders need to be calibrated before use. Press the button against the wall until it’s ready, then begin scanning.
Non-standard wall types: Walls made of plaster, lath, or those with double drywall layers can confuse both magnetic and electronic models.

By identifying the specific problem, you can adjust your technique and turn incorrect readings into reliable results.

How to Find a Stud in a Wall Without a Stud Finder

If your stud finder isn’t cooperating, there are other ways to locate a wood stud. Here are some alternative methods to try:

Look for outlets and switches: Electrical outlets and light switches are usually attached to studs. Measure about 16 inches from one side to find the next stud, as most stud spacing is 16 or 24 inches apart.
Tap the wall: Knock lightly along the wall and listen for a solid sound instead of a hollow sound. The solid sound usually indicates the stud location.
Check for nail pops or seams: In older homes, you might spot small bumps from nail heads or seams in the drywall revealing the location.
Use a powerful magnet: A strong magnet (rare-earth magnets or strong neodymium magnets) can help you locate screws or nails embedded in the wall, which will often point to studs in drywall.
Drill pilot holes: I commonly use the exploratory hole method when I know I'm close. Drill into the wall and poke a wire hanger of finishing nail in there. If you hit wood, you're good. Sometimes I bend about 3-inches into an L-shape, poke it through my hole and try to rotate it, if you hit something solid you know you're close.

These methods might not be as precise as using a stud finder, but they can give you a good starting point. Once you find one, mark it with a pencil mark and measure to find others.

Tips for Getting Accurate Readings With Your Stud Finder

Here are some quick tips to improve the accuracy of stud detection:

Start scanning from a known flat, unobstructed area.
Move the device slowly and steadily.
Make sure you’re holding it flat against the wall and in the correct mode (if there are different scan modes).
Calibrate the device every time you turn it on.
Know how many layers of drywall you're dealing with.
Replace the battery if results seem inconsistent.
Avoid areas with obvious obstructions like pipes or large electrical outlets.

Following these steps can save you time and frustration while helping you get the results you need.

FAQ

Why does my stud finder beep randomly?

This often happens when the device picks up something other than a stud. It could be detecting electrical wires, pipes, or irregularities in the wall. Try recalibrating the device and scanning again at a slower pace. If you’re still getting random beeps, check for low battery power or consider whether your wall type might be causing issues.

Can I use my smartphone to find a stud?

Yes, there are stud finder apps that use your phone’s sensors to detect studs. Some apps rely on the phone’s built-in magnetometer to locate metal screws or nails, similar to a magnetic version. While these apps can work in a pinch, they’re generally less accurate than a dedicated stud finder.

This article first appeared on Men's Journal and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads: