Constant Caddie Change A Plus Or Negative?

With all of the PGA Tour news and updates, one that is starting to gain more traction surrounds the talk in replacing caddies. Many Tour players this 2025 season have already replaced their designated caddies, for many reasons. Some having to due with injuries like Matt Minister who had to be replaced due to a back injury. On the other side of things, are the caddies who are relieved of their duties but afterwards not replaced. Seeing this most recently and sparking discussions, with veteran Max Homa and his outing at the U.S. Open Final Qualifying. Homa parted ways with caddie Bill Harke resulting in the carrying of his own bag for 36 holes. So, the question now arises of how Tour athletes maneuver in situations where caddies can not be replaced. 

Caddies Under Appreciated? 

When looking at names in the PGA Tour like Scottie Scheffler, Justin Thomas, Max Homa, the discussion is often on their impressive skill sets. In the background of all the fame and career earnings, are the dedicated personal caddies. Caddies who play more than a help role during the season, some even becoming true family friends. Recently Homa was highlighted for releasing his and the impact it had on his performance. 

“I’d much rather talk about the golf instead of all the questions about the caddie…. I’m good. Just hoofed it 36,” Homa said. 

Seeming to deflect from media questions, the visible toll taken on Homa explained things for itself. It’s the small things like a caddie carrying a bag around, that is overlooked by not just athletes but fans as well. Homa has had his fair share of caddie changes, with one prior in Joe Greiner due to friendship. Being able to switch and drop caddies is a plus for Tour players, but in most cases a negative for the caddies. 

The Harsh Reality 

Sometimes the truth hurts, and that seems to be the case for caddies during this 2025 season of play. One caddie in particular who seems to be head of the food chain, is Ted Scott. Scott represented Scottie Scheffler, and secured wins on the regular. When comparing Scott to those who are struggling to find something permanent, it becomes a slippery slope. Maybe the problem is not with Tour caddies but the players themselves.