Yardbarker
x
The best Halloween candy, ranked
Barry Chin/The Boston Globe via Getty Images

The best Halloween candy, ranked

One of the most important parts of Halloween is sorting through the goodie bag after a long night of ringing doorbells, putting on the scariest faces and begging just "one more block" as the sun goes down. Ranking candy isn't just for fun, it's an important part of deciding what you can trade with your brothers and sisters, and knowing which pieces dad is going to sneak from your stash later.

While we might not all agree on what is the very best candy around Halloween, at least we can all agree on this: treats are much better than tricks.

 
1 of 36

#35 Bubble Gum

#35 Bubble Gum
Pouya Dianat/Atlanta Braves/Getty Images

The hard pieces of bubble gum always end up being relegated to the bottom depths of our Halloween candy bags. 

 
2 of 36

#34 Jolly Ranchers

#34 Jolly Ranchers
Jerry Cleveland/The Denver Post via Getty Images

Not only do Jolly Ranchers always get stuck in our teeth, but we always end up with the dreaded green apple. More trick than treat if you ask us. 

 
3 of 36

#33 Nerds

#33 Nerds
David Livingston/Getty Images

Generally we love Nerds candy, but on Halloween we want all the chocolate we can get!

 
4 of 36

#32 Ring Pop

#32 Ring Pop
Topps via Getty Images

A candy ring always sounded like a good idea, until you actually get one and then it turns out it's just a good way to end up with sticky hands and candy covered with dirt. 

 
5 of 36

#31 Bit-O-Honey

#31 Bit-O-Honey
The Washington Post via Getty Images

When the neighbor kids are too loud, we threaten to give them Bit-O-Honey at Halloween. Unfortunately, they're kids and were born in the 2010s and not the 1940s and have no idea what a terrible threat this is to their candy haul.

 
6 of 36

#30 Necco Wafers

#30 Necco Wafers
Robert Lachman/Los Angeles Times via Getty Images

Candy that exists to share with your mom on Halloween because she's just going to pilfer them all from your treat bag when you go to sleep anyway. 

 
7 of 36

#29 Smarties

#29 Smarties
KAREN BLEIER/AFP/Getty Images

The combination of both tart and chalky is problematic enough to drag Smarties down in the Halloween power rankings.

 
8 of 36

#28 Wax Teeth

#28 Wax Teeth
FilmMagic/Getty Images

We're not even sure if this is candy. Goes in your mouth, but it's also got the word 'wax' in it and we tend not to eat candles year-round.

 
9 of 36

#27 Lifesavers

#27 Lifesavers
Tim Boyle/Getty Images

Lifesavers are the safety candy of the Halloween haul. If one piece isn't to your liking, the next one probably will be the cherry-flavored one you were looking for.

 
10 of 36

#26 Candy Corn

#26 Candy Corn
John Block/Getty Images

Many people like to say candy corn is the worst Halloween candy, which is totally not true because there are at least two more candies before it on this list.

 
11 of 36

#25 Candy Pumpkins

#25 Candy Pumpkins
Bloomberg via Getty Images

Candy corn, but with better PR of being pumpkin-shaped. Also they're bigger than candy corn and more is always better, so they rank ahead of the generally low-ranked candy corn.

 
12 of 36

#24 Clementines

#24 Clementines
Digital Light Source/UIG via Getty Images

Someone did NOT just drop a piece a fruit into our candy bag. Probably friends with the dentist.

 
13 of 36

#23 Butterfingers

#23 Butterfingers
The Washington Post via Getty Images

Ever have a Butterfinger and not end up with crumbs all over your costume? If you have, it's because someone handed out Butterfingers they bought in 2003.

 
14 of 36

#22 Popcorn Balls

#22 Popcorn Balls
Meryl CA/Getty Images

When you're an older child and your parents insist you share with your younger family members who cannot keep up with your trick-or-treating prowess, the popcorn ball is the first treat to be handed over willingly.

 
15 of 36

#21 Carmel Apples

#21 Carmel Apples
Heather Perry/Getty Imaes

When you want fruit and you also want to finally get rid of the loose tooth that's been bothering you.

 
16 of 36

#20 Candied Apples

#20 Candied Apples
Philippe Marion/Getty Images

Candied apples are great because you and your siblings can fight with them, knock each other out with these sugary battle axes and recover just in time to get them stuck in your hair.

 
17 of 36

#19 Tāffy

#19 Tāffy
Tom Herde/The Boston Globe via Getty Images

It's not that tāffy's bad, you just don't know what flavor you're getting until you've unwrapped it and no one is going to trade you for a chocolate banana tāffy when you're clearly offering a re-wrapped orange cream tāffy in exchange.

 
18 of 36

#18 Good & Plenty

#18 Good & Plenty
The Washington Post via Getty Images

Like Good & Plenty? Good, there will be plenty of them left for you.

 
19 of 36

#17 Pretzels and Crackers

#17 Pretzels and Crackers
Mel Melcon/Los Angeles Times via Getty Images

Some well-meaning family in your neighborhood is going attempt to give out crackers or pretzels as a healthy alternative to sugary treats at Halloween. When their kid-having friends laugh at them and says no child wants pretzels they'll race to the store at 4 p.m. on October 31 to correct their error and spend the next six months eating pumpkin-shaped pretzels.

 
20 of 36

#16 Halloween Peeps

#16 Halloween Peeps
Kirk Mckoy/Los Angeles Times via Getty Images

It used to be that you could only combine marshmallow and sugar at Easter, but now you can look forward to debating "fresh or stale" just about any holiday. Bonus, they make killer s'mores.

 
21 of 36

#15 Pennies

#15 Pennies
Tim Boyle/Getty Images

The sign of the house that forgot to buy Halloween candy but doesn't have the courage to turn off the porch light and hide under the covers, more than a few pennies will end up in trick-or-treat bags this Halloween, ignoring the approximately 2,732 articles written about the death of the penny since 1979.

 
22 of 36

#14 Lollipop

#14 Lollipop
Rick Loomis/Los Angeles Times via Getty Images

Candy most likely to be allowed by parents to be enjoyed while still trick-or-treating.

 
23 of 36

#13 Toothbrush

#13 Toothbrush
Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

You've found the dentist's house.

 
24 of 36

#12 Jelly Beans

#12 Jelly Beans
Lauri Patterson/Getty Images

Jelly beans are the candy to eat while you sort the good candy from the bad candy.

 
25 of 36

#11 Skittles

#11 Skittles
Otto Greule Jr/Getty Images

There are so many varieties of Skittles, we can't get enough of these chewy, fruit bits these days. One of the best Halloween candies that isn't chocolate.

 
26 of 36

#10 Nestle Crunch

#10 Nestle Crunch
Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

Nestle Crunch bars aren't for everyone. They're a touch sweeter and some people think the crunch isn't enough to rise above the pack, but let's face it, it's the first chocolate bar you have as a kid that isn't just plain chocolate.

 
27 of 36

#9 3 Muskeeters

#9 3 Muskeeters
The Washington Post via Getty Images

We know we really like 3 Musketeers and their soft nougaty centers, but we're not just that excited for them. A double when we're looking for late-October home runs. 

 
28 of 36

#8 Chocolate Bars

#8 Chocolate Bars
Scott Olson/Getty Images

A classic icon is a classic icon for a reason and no one should be disappointed in perfectly good chocolate bar.

 
29 of 36

#7 Coffee Crisp

#7 Coffee Crisp
Carlos Osorio/Toronto Star via Getty Images

Crispie chocolate wafer bars with a hint of coffee favor. Sadly, they're a Canadian delicacy so we're all going to have to move to north of the border to trick-or-treat this year to get them. Wait, did we say 'flavor' for these treats? We meant 'flavour' (if it got us a Coffee Crisp).

 
30 of 36

#6 Strawberry Licorice

#6 Strawberry Licorice
The Washington Post via Getty Images

Any candy that doubles as a straw gets to automatically jump three spots up the Halloween candy ranking.

 
31 of 36

#5 M&M's

#5 M&M's
Stephen Chernin/Getty Images

Few things are as fun to play with and eat as M&M's candy. Even better is sorting them by color because you're convinced the green ones taste better than the red ones. It's true! They do!

 
32 of 36

#4 Kit Kats

#4 Kit Kats
Carlos Osorio/Toronto Star via Getty Images

Did someone say Kit Kat bars? Sweet cream sandwich waters covered in chocolate? I won't even ask you to 'smell my feet' when I ring your doorbell if you have Kit Kats.

 
33 of 36

#3 Twix

#3 Twix
The Washington Post via Getty Images

Candy and a cookie all in one bite? Halloween is the best holiday of the season, and that's before we get to the caramel. 

 
34 of 36

#2 Gummy Bears

#2 Gummy Bears
Ben Hider/Getty Images

The are few things as addictive as chewy, fruity sweet gummy bears. The only thing we don't like about them is there never enough in the bag!

 
35 of 36

#1-Tie Snickers

#1-Tie Snickers
Mustafa Kamaci/Anadolu Agency/Getty Images

The candy bar that has more kids yelling "No, dad, you can only take one this is my candy!" on Halloween than any other.

 
36 of 36

#1-Tie Reese's Peanut Butter Cups

#1-Tie Reese's Peanut Butter Cups
The Washington Post via Getty Images

Remember the first time you went trick-or-treating on Halloween and you realized people gave away some of the best candy away in exchange for saying 'please' and 'thank you' at their door? That was the first time you got a Reese's Peanut Butter Cup in your treat bag.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

+

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.