Aaron Judge is the captain of the New York Yankees. He's the sixteenth captain in Yankees history and undoubtedly their best player. While Judge hasn't had his best performances during the postseason throughout his 10-year-career, he continues to play at an MVP level year-after-year in the regular season.
Another Yankees player, however, did have the best performance of their career in the postseason. On Thursday night, in a win-or-go-home, American League Wild Card Game 3 against the Boston Red Sox, Cam Schlittler put his best foot forward. With a capacity crowd of 48,883 inside Yankee Stadium, standing and cheering on their feet nearly all night, rookie pitcher, Schlittler pitched the game of his life.
Taking the mound for the first time ever in the postseason, Schlitter not only helped his team advance to the AL Division Series, he made MLB postseason history. Schlittler, at just 24 years old, with just 73 MLB innings under his belt, became the first pitcher in MLB postseason history to have 12 strikeouts, zero walks, while pitching at least eight innings.
Judge, despite his 0-for-3 performance in Game 3, had nothing but complimentary things to say about Schlittler during his postgame interview. Judge remained composed for his interview despite Austin Wells dumping champagne on Judge's head halfway through the interview with YES Network's Meredith Marakovits.
"He did something real special," Judge said.
"He did something real special."
— YES Network (@YESNetwork) October 3, 2025
Aaron Judge reacts to Cam Schlittler's historic postseason debut. pic.twitter.com/n4kOQ4j6a0
Judge went on to say how impressed he was with Schlittler's "composure" on such a grand stage. In a world where starting pitchers don't often see the eighth inning, Schlittler certainly forced Yankees' manager, Aaron Boone's hand on Thursday night.
With Schlittler arriving at 100 pitches as he earned strikeout No. 12 to close the book on inning No. 7, Boone could be seen (on ESPN's broadcast) turn to his pitching coach, Matt Blake, and mouth something to the effect of, "he's still throwing strikes".
Whenever Boone came to the realization he was going to leave his rookie pitcher in for the eighth inning is irrelevant. Schlittler was able to hand the ball to closer, David Bednar, who kept the game right where it was, 4-0.
With the impressive win, the Yankees will now head north of the border to take on their AL East, division rival, Toronto Blue Jays. The ALDS will get started on Saturday at 4:08 p.m. EDT on FOX. While the starting pitchers haven't been announced for Game 1 as of early Friday morning, it appears Schlittler will get a chance to follow up his historic performance at some point during the ALDS.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!