
MLB.com’s Mark Feinsand is reporting that the New York Mets agreed to a three-year deal with Bo Bichette to play third base in 2026. In all of my circles this never was something that was talked about. We thought, another middle infielder? No way. Well, the versatile Bo Bichette can play a lot of positions.
When Kyle Tucker went to the Dodgers last night, you can bet that two things happened. First, David Stearns, the GM of the Mets dropped an F-bomb and then, he looked down the list of remaining free agents possibly saying the magic word again. The list is getting thin.
I call refer to Bo Bichette as "Dante’s Inferno" as he is the son of Major League Baseball great Dante Bichette, who had a solid career with many teams but is best known for playing with the Colorado Rockies. He finished second in the MVP voting in 1995 where he amassed 40 home runs and 128 RBI.
Let’s break down this signing for one of my favorite players. From a fantasy perspective, we will run through Rules of Engagement to at least explain what the risk is.
After leading the league in hits in both 2021 and 2022, he continued to put up strong numbers in 2023, posting .306 batting average with 20 home runs and an .814 OPS, showing his typical combination of contact and power from the shortstop position. However, his 2024 season was marred by injury and inconsistency; in just 81 games, he hit .225 with only 4 homers and a .598 OPS, a significant dip from his usual performance and well below his career norms.
Bichette rebounded strongly in 2025, reasserting himself as one of MLB’s more productive everyday hitters. His power wasn’t there as he hit just 18 home runs, but 94 RBIs, and a robust .311 batting average, ranking among the league’s better bats in aggregate. A late-season PCL knee sprain sidelined him down the stretch showing his fragility so this is a tough signing and someone to be careful of on your fantasy team.
Wow. The Mets have many players capable of playing third base: Brett Baty, Mark Vientos, Luisangel Acuna, Ronny Mauricio, Jorge Polanco, but let’s add another because he can play shortstop and second base. Oh yeah, The Mets are loaded with players who can play those positions as well. What they needed was an outfielder. So let’s see what a lineup looks like. Bichette can likely spot right into two spot with his speed, batting average, eye and ability to sacrifice when necessary.
One possible Lineup:
Note: IMHO, there is no way that Tyrone Taylor will play against right-handed pitching. Benge can play center and so can Jared Young who is left-handed. So we will see a lot of different players in the nine spot and may even see Brett Baty in LF as Mark Vientos hits both handed pitchers and could win the DH job.
One of the biggest drivers of fantasy value is the ability to get on and Bichette can do that. He has been one of the best hitters when healthy.
The big worry is HEALTH.
What to expect from Bichette? Expect him to hit 20 home runs but likely drive in 100 runs with Lindor and Soto in front of him. Don’t expect him to run more as that has slowed since his amazing seasons of 2021 and 2022.
Rule 2 says that Injuries Matter. The knee injury last year was for colliding with a catcher. That was a freaky thing. The hand injuries are a lot more to worry about. As I wrote earlier this week, the turf causes more injuries especially for infielders so this is VERY good for Bo. He is an incredible hitter and if healthy, he should bloom.
Rule 3, says: “Do not pay big bucks for free agents who signed big contracts to play in a new city. Adjustments (to a new city, new teammates, new place to live, etc.) take a couple of months and as a result, year-long stats suffer. ”
Not sure this will be as much the case from someone like Bo Bichette as he comes from a lineage that understands that baseball is FIRST. He will have some clubhouse adjustments and New York is a hard place to play. I would discount him a bit for that.
So, I likely will not own many shares of Bo Bichette because I am strict to the rules, but suggest you test your own risk tolerance and also decide if it is too much fun NOT to have the Inferno on your team.
Baseball is Life.
Is Bo Bichette playing third base for the Mets?
Yes. The Mets signed Bo Bichette with the expectation that he will handle third base while retaining infield flexibility.
Does Bo Bichette gain fantasy value with the Mets?
Yes. Batting behind Francisco Lindor and Juan Soto significantly boosts his RBI and run-scoring potential.
Should fantasy managers worry about Bichette’s injuries?
Health is the main concern. Knee and hand injuries have limited him recently, so risk tolerance matters.
Is Bo Bichette still a five-category fantasy player?
Mostly four categories now. Batting average and RBIs remain elite, while steals are no longer a major part of his game.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!