USA TODAY Sports

Braves Weigh Catching Depth as Sean Murphy’s Health Remains a Question Mark

Originally posted on Athlon Sports | By Jeremy Lockett | Last updated Feb 7, 2025 9:18 AM ET

As the Atlanta Braves gear up for another championship chase in 2025, one position remains under quiet scrutiny: catcher. Sean Murphy, an All-Star backstop and a crucial piece of Atlanta’s lineup, is as reliable as they come when healthy. But that’s precisely the issue—the Braves are wary of his injury history and are taking a calculated approach to ensure they aren’t caught off guard if he misses time.

Murphy’s talent isn’t in question. Since arriving in Atlanta, he has provided elite defense behind the plate while maintaining strong offensive production. His ability to handle a pitching staff, frame pitches effectively, and control the running game makes him one of the top catchers in the league. However, past injuries have forced the Braves to consider contingency plans. While there’s no immediate concern, the team understands that having a reliable backup is essential for navigating a 162-game season.

That’s where Drake Baldwin enters the picture. The young catcher has emerged as an intriguing asset for the Braves, displaying impressive hitting metrics that suggest he could contribute at the major league level sooner rather than later. While his catching skills are still developing, Baldwin’s offensive potential makes him a valuable piece in the Braves’ long-term plans. The organization isn’t just looking at him as a backup catcher—they see him as a potential designated hitter or even an everyday player down the line.

With Baldwin’s stock rising, there has been speculation about whether the Braves might move him in a trade to address other areas of need. However, sources indicate that Atlanta is hesitant to part ways with him. Given Murphy’s injury history and the lack of depth at the catching position, the Braves want to ensure they have insurance behind the plate. Trading Baldwin could leave them vulnerable if Murphy were to miss significant time.

Beyond Murphy and Baldwin, the Braves are also exploring the possibility of bringing back former players for strategic depth. Whether through free agency or trade, Atlanta is keeping its options open to solidify the roster for what they hope will be another deep postseason run.

Ultimately, the Braves’ approach is one of caution and foresight. While Murphy remains their clear-cut starter, they are taking the necessary steps to ensure they are covered if injuries arise. Baldwin’s development gives them flexibility, and unless the right trade comes along, he is likely to remain a key part of Atlanta’s future plans. With a championship window still wide open, the Braves are making sure no position—especially one as crucial as catcher—is left to chance.

This article first appeared on Athlon Sports and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads: