New York Yankees News

Home

Quizzes

Watch

Newsletter

Could the Yankees Shake Up Tradition With Alternate Jerseys?

DETROIT, MICHIGAN – OCTOBER 08: Spencer Torkelson #20 of the Detroit Tigers celebrates with Dillon Dingler #13 after scoring a run against the Seattle Mariners during the sixth inning of game four of the American League Division Series at Comerica Park on October 08, 2025 in Detroit, Michigan. (Photo by Gregory Shamus/Getty Images)

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Could the Yankees Shake Up Tradition With Alternate Jerseys?

Originally posted on Just Baseball | By Patrick Walsh | Last updated May 2, 2026 9:50 AM ET

Add us as a preferred source on Google

In recent weeks, New York Yankees players have reportedly lobbied the team brass to use their navy blue practice jersey as a new alternate uniform, according to The Athletic. Although not a huge shift in design, it would be a notable break for the franchise, which has only ever worn the traditional pinstripe home uniforms and grey away uniforms, with minimal changes.

MLB approved the alternate uniforms for regular season use ahead of the 2025 season, according to a Yankees representative. They have yet to make their on-field debut.

This follows a trend of the club, long known as one of the most traditional franchises in sports, lightening itself up a little. The most famous example of this happened last year, when the team made changes to its famous no-beards policy, allowing team members to have “well-groomed beards.”

These changes have been praised and criticized by different sides of the fanbase, as well as lampooned by Yankee haters.

There are pros and cons to the possibility of new uniforms and what they would mean for the image of the franchise. It is an interesting topic, as for almost any other team, there would be little to no fanfare over the addition of a jersey, which happens constantly throughout sports these days.

Adding a Third Jersey: Pros

The Yankees potentially adding a third jersey could have a lot of pros. First off, more jerseys means more jerseys to sell, which creates more revenue for the team and the league, as well as sporting goods stores and websites that sell them.

But beyond just the monetary benefit, it would diversify the look of the club. The pinstripes are iconic and will never go away, but many other franchises with similar proud heritages have begun to shift toward the uniform revolution of modern sports.

Just take the 16 teams (including the Yankees) that existed before the first two MLB expansion teams (the Angels and Senators/Rangers) joined in 1961. The longevity of these franchises is what draws a lot of people to the game and keeps baseball as America’s pastime.

Despite that history, all of these teams have gone through numerous uniform changes over the years, for better or for worse, depending on your opinion, but almost all of them still have some reference to their historic past.

For example, the Tigers have not changed their home uniform since 1934, yet have had multiple iterations of road and alternate uniforms. That has helped the team both look the part as the years went on, as well as hold on to its history.

Looking beyond baseball, plenty of iconic franchises have added alternates while keeping their brand intact. The Dallas Cowboys, Pittsburgh Steelers and Los Angeles Lakers have largely kept their core looks while adding alternate jerseys. The Yankees shouldn’t be afraid of a minor change like this.

And besides, they have already done it. The Yankees participated in the Players Weekend nickname jerseys from 2017-19, marking the first time in their history that players’ names were on the back of the team’s jerseys. They also have a sleeve sponsorship patch like every other team in the league.

That was exactly what captain Aaron Judge referenced to The Athletic when asked about all this, saying, “I’m all about tradition, but we’ve got a patch on our sleeves.”

Adding a Third Jersey: Cons

I think that the pros of adding a third jersey outweigh the cons, but for the sake of argument, they must be considered.

The first con of the alternate jersey conundrum is the fact that it is a conundrum to begin with. Only the New York Yankees would have a topic like this bring attention to the team, despite the team’s current AL East-leading record.

If any other team wanted a new jersey, they would just do it. And if the fans didn’t like it, they would eventually get rid of it.

The only anti-alternate jersey opinion that I can think of is the antithesis of one of the pros I previously mentioned. The intimidation factor that surrounds playing in the Bronx comes from the team’s traditions. It’s what helped keep the Yankees hold on to that factor when they moved into their new stadium in 2009.

Adding a third jersey could lighten the way other players and teams view the Yankees. Then again, it should not be an issue, as the new jersey is supposed to be just an away jersey.

The real issue with adding a jersey is all the attention that would come with it. For the same reason that fans love the team’s tradition and history, haters love to make fun of it.

Let’s take the reversal of the beard ban. The ban was put in place by legendary Yankees owner George Steinbrenner, who wanted his players to look professional on the field. The decision was ridiculed for years by fans and sportswriters.

In recent years, it even caused the team to struggle to acquire certain players. Cy Young Award winner David Price said that he would not join the Yankees because of their policy. One of the driving forces behind the ban being revoked was the team’s trade for Devin Williams last offseason.

Though I don’t think that adding a new jersey would cause the front office any difficulties, the amount of attention that a new jersey would bring could be similar.

This debate over a new jersey has not been a damper on the team’s play, as they continue to look red hot. It is just an interesting facet of the Yankees being the iconic franchise that they are, as no other team in baseball and few others in sports could find itself in a similar situation.

It will be worth following to see if/when the Yankees ever actually wear an alternate jersey, but until then, it will continue to be a unique debate for Yankees fans, and haters, to have.

This article first appeared on Just Baseball and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads: