Explaining why Anthony Siegler continues to get at-bats with the Brewers

Once a first-round pick and the 23rd overall selection by the Yankees, Siegler joined the Brewers on a minor league deal last offseason. Prior to his July 1 call-up, he was producing strong numbers in the minors, posting a .277/.416/.465 slash line. So despite his current struggles at the big league level, hitting just .194/.292/.210, it’s not as if he lacks offensive ability, although historically, big slugging numbers are not in his nature, but that’s that case for several Milwaukee players.

Putting the surface-level stats aside, Siegler is consistently delivering quality plate appearances and making smart swing decisions. He’s chasing just 18% of pitches outside the strike zone, 10% lower than the MLB average, showing strong discipline. While his 3.78 pitches seen per plate appearance is just below league average, that number gains value when paired with his selective approach. Siegler routinely swings at hittable pitches and avoids chasing, which suggests the Brewers believe it’s only a matter of time before the results start to follow.

Do splits play a role in Anthony Sielger continuing to get opportunity?

Perhaps. Siegler, a left-handed hitter, offers a natural platoon advantage against right-handed pitchers, which is likely a factor in his continued playing time. While this isn’t a knock on Caleb Durbin, who’s actually held his own against righties with a .252/.325/.385 slash line, although the numbers suggest he performs even better against lefties (.270/.342/.430).

Given this split, using Siegler against right-handers makes strategic sense, especially when matchups favor a lefty bat. It’s less about one outperforming the other overall and more about maximizing situational advantages.

One final point worth noting is that the Brewers emphasize a competitive clubhouse culture. While Siegler hasn’t produced eye-popping results, and has had a few blunders defensively, his quality at-bats and plate discipline right now are enough to earn him continued opportunity. That dynamic should only motivate Durbin to make the most of his chances when he’s in the lineup.

In the end, this internal competition pushes both players to raise their game and that is a scenario that can only benefit Milwaukee.