x
Fantasy Baseball 2026: Closer Confidential for Week 6
© Denis Poroy-Imagn Images

Bullpens were already in chaos across Major League Baseball, but April showers apparently bring May injury bugs. The Orioles back end is suddenly in a Land of Confusion after closer Ryan Helsley landed on the IL with the dreaded elbow injury. Kenley Jansen has a groin issue that, as of now, has not landed him on the IL, but bears watching.

And the carousel spun again over the last week, so let’s get to work.

Reviewing the Categories

In the weekly Closer Confidential column, we group closers, and committees, into three cohorts:

  • Secure: 90 and Above - Low-to-no risk; good results, strong underlying statistics
  • Shaky: 80-89 – Some doubt exists, often with inconsistent supporting skills/stats
  • Seesaw: 79 and Below – Committees and closers in trouble. 9th inning is (or should be) in doubt.

Secure Closers

David Bednar continues delivering consistent saves with strong underlying metrics, reinforcing his stable ninth-inning role outlook.Kevin Jairaj-Imagn Images

Every week we take another team out of the Secure cohort. This week, Ryan Helsley, who just graduated to Secure last week, hit the IL with elbow issues, so that situation is not even shaky. Check the Seesaw group for those names likely to get chances. We’ve moved the Mets, Phillies and now the Orioles bullpens out of this top group and we worry for those who remain.

Closer Next Option(s) Confidence Grade Last Week’s Score

Mason Miller - SD

Jason Adam, Adrian Morejon, Jeremiah Estrada (inj)

97

96

Cade Smith – CLE

Hunter Gaddis

93

93

David Bednar – NYY

Camilo Doval

93

92

Andres Munoz – SEA

Matt Brash

90

90

Changes in Confidence Grade or Closer Status in bold

Shaky Closers

Robert Suárez continues to perform well, but I’ll keep him at 89 for now until I get indications about what will happen when Iglesias returns. There is potential trouble in Detroit with Kenley Jansen having what seems to be a minor groin issue. I anticipate some IL news, but I don’t have a crystal ball so I’ll hold steady until we know more. But Kyle Finnegan is again a name you should know. Pete Fairbanks landed on the IL with a nerve issue in his wrist/hand so the Marlins called up Tyler Phillips who will get some high leverage opportunities, but they are down in seesaw until we see more. Riley O’Brien has been very impressive. I anticipate he will be at or near the top of this group quickly. But small sample size so far….

Closer Next Option(s) Confidence Grade Last Week’s Score

Robert Suárez – ATL

Tyler Kinley, Raisel Iglesias (inj)

89

89

Aroldis Chapman – BOS

Garrett Whitlock

88

88

Devin Williams – NYM

Luke Weaver

86

86

Brad Keller* - PHI

Jose Alvarado*, Orion Kerkering, Jhoan Duran (inj.)

85

85

Tanner Scott* - LAD

Alex Vesia*, Blake Treinan, Edwin Díaz (inj.)

85

85

Kenley Jansen – DET

Will Vest, Kyle Finnegan

84

84

Emilio Pagan – CIN

Tony Santillan

83

83

Caleb Thielbar* – CHC

Ben Brown*, Daniel Palencia (inj)

82

82

Riley O’Brien – STL

JoJo Romero, Ryne Stanek, Matt Svanson

81

76

Changes in Confidence Grade or Personnel in bold

Seesaw Situations

Jakob Latz emerging as speculative saves option despite limited strikeout rates and uncertain long-term closer role outlook.Rick Osentoski-Imagn Images

Jakob Latz now has 3 saves for the Rangers while demonstrating good control. I’m not a huge fan of his stuff as he’s not striking out batters at typical closer rates, but I bumped him to the top of the seesaw group. I want to see more and will look closer in Week 6. I bumped up Bryan Baker a few points as he’s looked comfortable in Tampa. The Baltimore group took a plunge from Helsley’s 90 Confidence Grade to an in flux score of 77. I’m not sure what it’s going to look like at Camden Yards, but I have a bad feeling it will be bad before it gets good. The Astros bullpen is a mess. But Josh Hader will be starting his minor league rehab stint and hopes to return later in May. I’m not certain what’s up on Anaheim as they have shared saves this week, so we’ll hold them steady for another week.

Closer Next Option(s) Confidence Grade Last Week’s Score

Paul Sewald - ARI

Jonathan Loáisiga

79

79

Abner Uribe – MIL

Trevor Megill

79

79

Lucas Erceg – KC

Matt Strahm, Carlos Estévez (inj)

79

79

Victor Vodnik* – COL

Antonio Senzatela*

79

79

Gregory Soto* - PIT

Dennis Santana*

79

79

Jakob Latz - TEX

Jakob Junis, Cole Winn

79

68

Seranthony Dominguez - CHW

Jordan Leisure, Jordan Hicks, Grant Taylor

79

79

Rico Garcia* – BAL

Andrew Kittredge, Keegan Akin

77

90

Louis Varland – TOR

Tyler Rogers, Jeff Hoffman

76

76

Tyler Phillips* – MIA

Anthony Bender*, Calvin Faucher, Pete Fairbanks (inj)

76

87

Bryan Baker - TB

Griffin Jax, Garrett Cleavinger (inj), Edwin Uceta (inj.)

76

72

Ryan Zeferjahn- LAA

Sam Bachman, Drew Pomeranz, Ben Joyce (inj), Robert Stevenson (inj), Kirby Yates (inj)

75

75

Gus Varland - WAS

PJ Poulin, Paxton Schultz

74

74

Erik Miller* - SF

Ryan Walker*

73

73

Enyel De Los Santos* - HOU

Bryan King*, Bryan Abreu (inj), Josh Hader (inj.)

72

79

Joel Kuhnel* - ATH

Hogan Harris*, Justin Sterner*

71

71

Justin Topa* - MIN

Eric Orze, Kody Funderburk

68

68

*Denotes Closer Committee
Changes in Confidence Grade or personnel in bold

2026 Fantasy Baseball Closer Questions, Answered

Who are the most secure closers heading into Week 6 2026?
The top arms with the clearest job security and highest projected save totals for the coming week are detailed in the report.

Which bullpens are in true committee situations right now?
Several high-leverage situations remain unsettled. The article breaks down current usage splits and projected save distribution.

Which low-rostered relievers are the best Week 6 waiver targets?
The highest-upside streamers and stash candidates still available in most leagues are highlighted with exact roster-percentage context.

How should I manage closers in daily lineup leagues during Week 6?
Prioritize the locked-in closers and use committee volatility for streaming the hot hand when matchups align.

Are any closers at risk of losing their job in the next 7–10 days?
Yes — the report identifies the highest-risk situations and the most likely replacements.

When does closer volatility typically settle down in 2026?
Most ninth-inning roles stabilize by late May or early June once injuries and early-season performance sort themselves out.

This article first appeared on Athlon Sports and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!