
When the Guardians win a tight and low-scoring game, it often gets described as “Guardsball” by announcers and others.
Part of the equation for the Guardians involves pitching, and they headed into this year’s tournament with a 3.77 ERA, which ranked eighth in the majors during the 162-game marathon. The area where Cleveland ranked even higher was 1,530 strikeouts, giving them the third-most behind the Phillies and Brewers.
A key cause of Cleveland’s pitching becoming a top-three strikeout team in a full season for the first time since 2017 was Gavin Williams, who did so well at East Carolina he went from a 30th-round pick by the Rays in 2017 to Cleveland’s first-round selection four years later.
Williams’ latest outing was another low-scoring game for the Guardians, who did not take the lead in Game 3 on Oct. 15 until he threw his final pitch.
He wound up striking out nine and allowed two runs and two hits in five innings and it occurred after he struck out 12 and allowed one hit in 5 2/3 innings in a 2-0 win in Game 5 of the ALDS against the White Sox.
Unlike Cam Schlittler, Williams is not necessarily doing this with a high-octane fastball. While his 18 four-seam fastballs averaged 97.6 mph, most of the right-hander’s success occurred with 29 sweepers.
It was slightly different from his 94-pitch outing to help eliminate the White Sox. In the clincher for Cleveland’s eighth ALCS trip, Willams relied on his curveball and sweeper. His 30 curveballs averaged 82.7 and his 29 sweepers averaged 88.
Earlier in the series, Williams took a different approach by relying on his four-seam fastball, which resembled a Schlittler outing when he averaged 99.5 on 38 four-seam fastballs while making his sweeper and curveball secondary options.
Through three postseason starts and a season-saving relief appearance in Game 4 against the White Sox, Williams has a 2.16 ERA. His 33 strikeouts are the most among any pitcher by a wide margin as Chris Sale finished with 19 strikeouts before the Braves were eliminated and three behind Orel Hershiser (1995) and Corey Kluber (2016) for the most in Cleveland postseason history with those performances occurring in World Series seasons.
Additionally Williams is holding hitters to a .140 average, the second-lowest mark among any pitcher still in the postseason behind teammate Cade Smith holding hitters to a .069 mark.
Two years ago when Cleveland lost a five-game ALCS to the Yankees, Williams was tasked with getting a split of the best-of-seven.
After Cleveland won on a dramatic walk-off in Game 3, Williams made his postseason debut and it did not go great. In an 8-6 loss, Williams lasted 2 1/3 innings while throwing 40 pitches and allowing homers to Juan Soto and Austin Wells on fastballs.
Coincidentally Soto was at the center of Williams going from 3-10 with a 4.86 ERA in 16 starts in 2024 to 12-5 with a 3.06 ERA in 31 starts during the 2025 season.
On Aug. 6, 2025, Williams took the Citi Field mound at 6-4 with a 3.33 ERA in 22 starts, which means he was already showing significant improvement from the previous two starts. By the end of the day, he was flirting with history and threatening to end Cleveland’s no-hit drought that extends all the way back to Len Barker in 1981.
Williams was two outs away from the magical no-hitter that creates extra work for some people (writers) and enjoyment for fans. Then Juan Soto lofted a fly ball to center field that went over the reach of Angel Martinez for a homer.
While the no-hit bid was gone, it was a signal of Williams’ arrival and it continued with six standout innings in the wild-card series against Detroit, though Cleveland took a 2-1 loss in that game.
In his near no-hit bid, it was a mostly fastball and curveball affair and the sweeper he deployed against Tampa Bay was thrown 11 times.
Williams used his four-seamer to contribute to nearly no-hitting the Mets in a year when opponents had a .268 average and 23.4% whiff rate. This year while throwing the pitch nearly 300 fewer times, hitters batted .192 and whiffed 31.8% of the time.
The biggest jump for Williams is the sweeper. He threw it about 300 more times from this year after not using it at all in 2023 and 2024.
Last season, Williams allowed a .181 average on the pitch and struck out 59 hitters with it. This year hitters who saw the pitch batted .158 and struck out 100 times in a season when he totaled 248 strikeouts, the 13th-most in team history.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!