Hal Steinbrenner Should Blame Himself for Yankees’ Collapse

This team was far from championship-caliber. Steinbrenner believed they were championship contenders, yet they couldn’t win a single game against the Rays, a feat even the 85-win Guardians managed.

The Yankees have lost the ability to recognize a championship-caliber team. They have had one World Series appearance since 2009, when the Dodgers bullied them and won 4-1. Their approach to building a team to win over 162 games doesn’t work in the playoffs.

They have spent $4 billion on payroll in that 17-year span and have nothing to show for it. Every year, something has been used as an excuse as to why they didn’t win. Look at the San Francisco Giants, Houston Astros and Los Angeles Dodgers. They made it work by winning multiple rings during that time, so why can’t the Yankees?

Whose Fault Was It Really?

The front office can point fingers at the players as much as it wants, but the people Steinbrenner puts in charge need to face consequences.

According to Steinbrenner, the Yankee offense was lackluster, but the men who assembled and managed it both did great jobs. Where in the world does that make sense? The short answer is it doesn’t.

Cashman handpicked the very hitters struggling on this roster. There is a phone book full of bad decisions he has made over the years that are just glossed over.

His bad decisions included two players not even on the roster making $16 million: DJ LeMahieu, who never played a playoff game after getting re-signed and Aaron Hicks, who was cut back in 2024. He also took on Josh Donaldson’s bloated contract long past his prime, and handed Jacoby Ellsbury a massive deal. These decisions were head-scratchers then and look even worse today.

While Cashman picks up the players, Boone manages the offense, and he did no better. Boone is a players’ first manager, which is why they love him, but at some point, the culture has to shift. They have zero accountability on offense during the season, and the postseason results of the past half-decade show that.

The last time Boone publicly criticized a player was when he benched Gleyber Torres in 2024 for not hustling. Since then, there has been no accountability, and the organization has ruled out this form of motivation.

This lack of accountability has gone on for the past six years. In 2020, Steinbrenner’s final remarks were no different from this year.

“Our offense—just inconsistent at playing up to their potential, to me,” Steinbrenner said. “You couldn’t tell which offense was going to show up.”

Six years later, the excuses are no different. No single position player on the Yankees’ 2020 ALDS roster started in this year’s ALDS, and both seasons ended with losses to Tampa. No progress has been made, Cashman gets a new contract and the cycle is set to repeat.

Trending in the Wrong Direction

The Yankees’ current approach is about as effective as wet paper. Everyone can see it, but the leadership will stay the same. If they won’t change the people who run the team, they have to change how they run it. They’re smart enough to calibrate the engine, but they aren’t willing to.

A desperate need to create urgency within the clubhouse and keep the team on their toes is needed. Fans aren’t asking for leadership like Billy Beane from “Moneyball,” where he caught his players dancing after a loss and berated them for it. Players have expectations, and Boone needs to call them out when needed.

The issue is Boone doesn’t seem like he will do that. He knows the game already beats players down and doesn’t want to add to it.

“There is probably a time and place for that, but generally speaking, to me that’s not leadership,” Boone said. “That’s me giving red meat to people that want to be upset with somebody.”

The Yankees made it clear that the team in 2026 won’t be the same going into next year. If Steinbrenner wants change, then he needs to change the way the team is led.