Yardbarker
Yardbarker
x
Here's Early Season Grades For Seattle Mariners 54 Games Into 2025
Seattle Mariners catcher Cal Raleigh (29) celebrates after hitting a home run against the Chicago White Sox on May 21 at Rate Field. David Banks-Imagn Images

The Seattle Mariners are officially a third of the way through the 2025 season. Entering Thursday, the Mariners have a 30-24 record and lead the American League West by half a game.

It's been a chaotic and surprising season for Seattle in several ways, and there will be more twists and turns before the year ends.

Here's some grades for the Mariners a third of the way through the season:

Offense

Seattle's offense has been one of the biggest shocks in the early part of 2025. The lineup was responsible for a large number of the team's wins during its nine-series win streak from April 7-May 7. Entering Thursday, the Mariners are sixth in the majors in home runs (73), 10th in RBIs (238), 10th in runs (247), 11th in OPS (.324) 11th in OPS (.722) and fourth in wRC+ (114).

Seattle's offense has started to slow down since its series win streak was snapped by the Toronto Blue Jays in a series May 9-11. From that point through Wednesday, the Mariners are slashing .220/.291/.364 with a .655 OPS and have struck out 175 times in 18 games.

The M's have overcome lengthy injuries to starters Luke Raley, Ryan Bliss and Victor Robles. The club has gotten contributions from up and down the lineup that have helped make up for the trio's absences.

Individual players like Jorge Polanco and Ben Williamson have seen their numbers regress after solid starts to the season, which has coincided with the offense slowing down.

Seattle's offense could go either direction at this point, and its current homestand is proof of that. The Mariners won 9-1 against the Washington Nationals on Tuesday and were shut out 9-0, also against the Nationals, on Wednesday.

At this point, the offense has done well enough overall to earn a positive grade.

Grade: B

Starting pitching

The starting rotation was the undisputed strength of the team going into the season. The unit boasted three All-Stars and Seattle was the only team that had four pitchers start 30 or more games in 2024.

This season, George Kirby, Logan Gilbert and Bryce Miller all landed on the 15-day injured list. In their stead, the Mariners went through much trial and error before settling on solild substitutions. Logan Evans and Emerson Hancock eventually settled into their roles on the rotation nicely. Evans had the longest outing for an M's starter this season and threw eight innings against Washington on Tuesday. Hancock has four quality starts in his last seven outings.

Luis Castillo has started to find his midseason form and Bryan Woo is the only pitcher in the American League to throw six or more innings in 10 starts. Kirby has made just two starts since being activated off the IL, and is still trying to regain his All-Star form. Miller struggled before landing on the IL, but received a cortisone shot for elbow inflammation that was responsible for a lot of his difficulties. Gilbert will begin his rehab assignment with the Triple-A Tacoma Rainiers on Thursday.

The starters have been significantly better in the last two weeks, but they'll need to sustain that for longer in order to earn a positive grade.

Grade: C

Bullpen

Seattle's bullpen has been the most volatile unit on the roster this season. Due to the rotation's struggles, the relievers have been at or near the top of the major leagues in innings pitched for most of 2025. The Mariners had to pull bullpen arms from Tacoma to make up for the high usage the first month of the season.

Like the rotation, the bullpen has started to settle in. Matt Brash and Jackson Kowar have both been activated off the injured list and have looked good in their respective outings. Carlos Vargas, who was on the roster bubble in spring training, has become a legitimate high-leverage reliever and the pecking order of the bullpen has become a lot more clear than it was at the beginning of the season.

Seattle also has arguably the best closer in baseball. Andres Munoz hasn't allowed an earned run (0.00 ERA), has struck out 28 batters in 22.2 innings across 23 appearances and has a league-leading 17 saves in 19 opportunities.

Entering Thursday, the Mariners are 10th in the majors in bullpen ERA (3.48) and tied for third in saves (18).

The early chaos, high usage and constant turnover dings Seattle's relievers slightly. But having Munoz, and the way the bullpen has pitched recently raises the overall grade.

Grade: B

This article first appeared on Seattle Mariners on SI and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!

TODAY'S BEST

Cincinnati Reds vs Philadelphia Phillies Game Delayed on Wednesday
MLB

Cincinnati Reds vs Philadelphia Phillies Game Delayed on Wednesday

The Cincinnati Reds vs Philadelphia Phillies game will be delayed on Wednesday due to weather in the area. Hunter Greene is set to make his first start for the Reds since the beginning of June. Christopher Sanchez is set to start for the Phillies. Sanchez has a 2.36 ERA and has been one of the best pitchers in Major League Baseball this season. The series is tied at one. The Reds are 63-58 and two games back of the third and final National League Wild Card spot. We will provide more updates as we have them regarding tonight's game.

Analyst’s bold take warns Commanders may have made huge offseason blunder
NFL

Analyst’s bold take warns Commanders may have made huge offseason blunder

The Washington Commanders are currently dealing with some wide receiver issues heading into the season. An NFL analyst poured more fuel on the fire by proclaiming that Adam Peters will regret a huge call earlier this offseason. Terry McLaurin is not practicing and hasn't for months as his contract battle with the Commanders goes on. Others lower down the depth chart are coming in for increasing criticism, which leaves general manager Adam Peters with a potential problem on his hands if they cannot turn the tide before Week 1. The Commanders' wideout regeneration began by letting Dyami Brown walk in free agency. Although the former third-round pick displayed much-improved performances down the stretch and into the playoffs, it wasn't enough for Peters to give him an extended stay. NFL analyst believes Commanders could regret letting Dyami Brown walk Brown ended up signing a one-year deal with the Jacksonville Jaguars that includes $9.5 million guaranteed. He's made his presence felt over the summer, drawing praise from quarterback Trevor Lawrence and head coach Liam Coen. This is the time of year he always flourished in Washington, but putting it together in a competitive setting was far more challenging. That didn't stop Brock Vereen of CBS Sports from labeling Brown as a sleeping giant ready to take over in 2025. The analyst thought his stock was low right now, but the Commanders could be kicking themselves for letting him go when it's all said and done. Stock right now is low on him because, 'Oh, Washington got rid of him. They replaced him with Deebo Samuel. He only landed a one-year deal.' This is a sleeping giant. Liam Coen knew exactly what he was doing. Dyami Brown is a versatile weapon. He can take handoffs, he can catch the ball, he can line up anywhere on the field. He even has pass attempts over his career. He can do everything and will be probably the most forgotten offensive weapon coming off of the Travis Hunter hype.Brock Vereen via SI Brown always flattered to deceive in Washington. He had every physical tool imaginable to be successful, but consistency never got close to the required standard. Peters takes sentiment out of every equation. The front-office leader didn't think the North Carolina product was worth what Jacksonville was willing to pay. And he pivoted accordingly. There probably won't be much regret around Brown's departure, regardless of whether he performs well with the Jaguars or not. He had countless chances to establish himself as a long-term option and almost always failed to deliver. If he'd done so, the Commanders would have rewarded him with a new deal. That wasn't the case. And there are still more questions than answers around Brown despite his promising start in the Florida sunshine. More Commanders news and analysis

Celtics' ownership move should concern Lakers governor Jeanie Buss
NBA

Celtics' ownership move should concern Lakers governor Jeanie Buss

Lakers governor Jeanie Buss is supposed to remain in charge of the team for years even after the sale. Given what just happened with the Boston Celtics, it might only be months. When the Grousbeck family sold the Celtics for $6.1B in March, ESPN reported that Wyc Grousbeck would stay on as the Celtics CEO and governor through the 2027-28 season. Now, new owner Bill Chisholm will take over once the sale is final. That should concern current Lakers team governor Jeanie Buss, whose family sold a majority interest in the Los Angeles Lakers to investor Mark Walter. Buss is supposed to stay on as team governor for "at least a number of years," according to ESPN's Ramona Shelburne, but new NBA owners haven't been keen on waiting to take control of teams recently. Mark Cuban thought he would continue running the Dallas Mavericks when he sold a controlling interest to the Adelson family in November 2023. Before the end of that season, when Dallas advanced to the NBA Finals, new team governor Patrick Dumont, the son-in-law of Miriam Adelson, was firmly in charge. General manager Nico Harrison reported directly to Dumont, which is how Luka Doncic ended up traded to the Lakers despite Cuban's objections. It might be different with the Lakers. Walter has owned a minority share in the Lakers since 2021, so he's had a working relationship with Buss. Her role as team governor may be a condition of the sale itself. With the team preparing for a long-term future with Doncic, Walter and his fellow owners might opt for continuity in the team governor role. But in general, people do not spend billions of dollars on a professional sports team so that someone else can be in charge. Buss is in charge of the Lakers now. Recent history says she won't be for long.

3 Ways Craig Berube Is Changing the Maple Leafs’ DNA
NHL

3 Ways Craig Berube Is Changing the Maple Leafs’ DNA

When Craig Berube took over behind the Toronto Maple Leafs bench in May 2024, it wasn’t just about swapping one coach for another. Toronto brought him in to change the way the team thinks, plays, and competes. Less about tweaks, more about rewiring the team’s DNA. DNA Change 1: The Maple Leafs Have Moved From Star Reliance to Team Accountability For years, the Maple Leafs leaned on pure offensive talent to cover for defensive lapses. Berube’s not buying it. Under his watch, everyone—from Auston Matthews to the last guy on the fourth line—is held to the same standard. If you don’t compete shift to shift, you won’t get minutes. That doesn’t mean the stars won’t shine, but they’ll have to do it while committing to a 200-foot game. Matthews’ defensive reads are now a feature, not a bonus. William Nylander is being pushed to round out his play. And role players like Matthew Knies or Nicolas Roy have a clear mandate: excel in your lane. DNA Change 2: The Maple Leafs Have Moved to Structure Over Chaos In the Berube era, the Maple Leafs won’t be the same freewheeling team fans have known. Expect layers of structure—consistent forechecking, five-man defensive units, and smarter puck management. It’s hockey built for playoff survival, not just regular-season fireworks. That might mean fewer highlight-reel plays, but it’s the kind of style that doesn’t break under pressure in May. Of course, the jury remains out on the success of this venture. DNA Change 3: The Maple Leafs Now See Culture as a Competitive Edge Perhaps Berube’s biggest shift is intangible: culture. He’s stripping away the drama and replacing it with clarity and purpose. In St. Louis, that approach turned a last-place roster into Stanley Cup champions in 2019. In Toronto, it’s already giving young players and depth guys a clear role, while keeping the stars invested in the same system. That unity—between front office, coaching staff, and players—is something the Maple Leafs have chased for years. If Matthews can emerge as a leader in this venture, all the better. The Maple Leafs Might Not Win Pretty, But … The 2025–26 Maple Leafs might not always win pretty, but if Berube’s changes stick, they’ll be harder to play against, more resilient in tight games, and less likely to beat themselves. And that, in Toronto, might be the real breakthrough.