Matt Holiday shares blunt Diamondbacks Nolan Arenado trade assessment

Holliday expanded on that view by emphasizing the financial imbalance and the limited return St. Louis accepted in the deal. The Cardinals sent Arenado along with approximately $31 million in cash, receiving right-handed pitcher Jack Martinez, a recent draft pick who has yet to make his professional debut.

From Arizona’s perspective, the move addresses a clear need at third base while adding elite defensive stability and veteran leadership. Arenado arrives with two seasons remaining on his contract at a significantly reduced annual cost, minimizing risk for a Diamondbacks team operating firmly in a win-now window.

The move also reflects the Diamondbacks’ broader commitment to capitalizing on recent postseason momentum, signaling confidence that a veteran core can accelerate contention while younger contributors continue to develop within a roster built to compete immediately.

As Spring Training draws near, the analysis of the Diamondbacks’ trade remains increasingly favorable to Arizona. The organization acquired an experienced veteran at a reduced cost, while St. Louis adopted a reset strategy that emphasizes payroll relief over imminent competitiveness.