
In signing Bo Bichette, the New York Mets have their 2026 infield sorted out.
Bichette will man the hot corner, sliding over from shortstop to third base for the first time as he enters his eighth major league season. On the other side will be Jorge Polanco, who is expected to play first for the Mets despite never starting a game there in his 12-year career. In the middle will be two seasoned veterans Francisco Lindor and Marcus Semien, who will be tasked with leading the aforementioned two through the adjustment period at their new positions.
This is to say, there doesn't appear to be an immediate need in the Mets infield. But moving forward, it's fair to assume that Semien (35), Polanco (32), and even Lindor (32) could take a step back in the coming years. Bichette will be entering his age-28 season but is only signed to a three-year deal that includes opt-outs after the first and second seasons.
Assuming the Mets will pay the additional $5 million bonus on top of his $42 million AAV to keep him if he opts out, they could still be left looking for a long-term solution at third base come 2029. Prior to his signing, New York was dealing with a potential logjam of youth at the position in emerging major leaguers Brett Baty, Mark Vientos, and Ronny Mauricio. But with their chances to get on the field seemingly evaporating, it appears increasingly likely that one, if not two is traded this offseason to address other needs.
That bring us to the minor league system, which ESPN ranked 1st among all organizations back in August. This includes MLB's top ranked RHP prospect Nolan McLean and seventh overall RHP Jonah Tong, along with the club's number one overall prospect Carson Benge. But gaining traction behind them is potentially the perfect successor to Bichette at third base: Jacob Reimer.
Reimer, 21, has played in 256 games for Mets minor league affiliates across four years, and holds a career .814 OPS. But last season is where the young infielder began to turn heads, slashing .282/.379/.491 with 17 home runs and 77 RBIs in 122 games (61 in High-A, 61 in Double-A). Reimer's impressive campaign caught the eye of many, including MLB.com's Jonathan Mayo, who ranked him second among all third base prospects.
The new Top 10 3B prospects list includes a player poised to make big U.S. debut, one who catapulted himself on the radar in the '25 AFL and one who's a high-floor power bat.
— MLB Pipeline (@MLBPipeline) January 20, 2026
Check out the list: https://t.co/wziYo72ZoM pic.twitter.com/VxUeO6fg27
According to Mayo's scouting, Reimer's best trait is his power, which grades at a 60 out of 80. This 'plus' level trait projects out as a high-20 to low-30 home run range across a full big-league season. As Mayo explained, "Reimer’s profile has shifted from a hit-over-power type to the other way around as he’s learned to turn on pitches more and get them in the air."
Reimer also drew an above-average ranking for his arm (55), which is an improvement on his last four scouting grades. After moving off of shortstop immediately upon signing with the Mets out of high school in 2022, Reimer has made strides in the field, getting the bulk of his playing time at third base while also playing first. This versatility could be his path to playing time earlier on, as the aging Polanco could reasonably end up as more of a DH with the ability to fill in around the infield than a full-time first baseman.
Jacob Reimer, the second best 3B prospect, per @MLBPipeline has light tower power! Here’s a 3 homer game last season #mets #lgm pic.twitter.com/oGcqNefbPf
— Master Flip (@Masterflip_) January 20, 2026
Regardless of fit, all signs point to Reimer making a push for the big leagues sooner rather than later. Currently ranked No. 6 in the Mets system and as Mayo suggests, likely just outside the MLB top 100, a fast start from Reimer in 2026 could reasonably push him towards a debut by the end of next summer.
At the same time, a player like Reimer could be the ideal trade chip in a trade for high-end pitching, which the Mets are reportedly eyeing. He would be a significant loss, but does not currently hold the same untouchable value of a McLean or Benge. As the club continues to be linked to starters like Freddy Peralta and MacKenzie Gore, Reimer is a potential option to get a deal done.
If you like our content, choose Sports Illustrated as a preferred source on Google.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!