The Subway Series between the New York Mets and New York Yankees is consistently one of the most compelling matchups in all of baseball. But this year had significantly more buzz with the league's new highest-paid player, Juan Soto, returning to his former stadium.
With the Mets and Yankees splitting the first two games, the series finale drew over 3 million viewers at its peak, becoming the most-watched Sunday Night Baseball game in seven years and the most-watched MLB game all season.
Sunday's Subway Series finale between the Mets and Yankees averaged 2.54 million viewers and peaked at 3.02 million, making it the most watched Sunday Night Baseball game in seven years, according to ESPN and Nielsen.
— Anthony DiComo (@AnthonyDiComo) May 20, 2025
It was also the most-watched 2025 MLB game on any platform.
The story of the series was Soto's return to Yankee Stadium. As fans did their best to terrorize the one-year Yankee, booing and turning their backs to him, Soto failed to deliver any significant moments throughout the series, going just 1-for-10 at the plate. Soto managed four walks and provided two stolen bases and two runs, but his lack of offensive production in this spotlight has caused many to question his $765 million price tag.
According to Mets manager Carlos Mendoza, Soto "embraced" Yankee Stadium's hostility. "He knew what was coming, and he didn't change, even though [Sunday] was pretty much the only game that we didn't see results."
But after Monday's loss to the Boston Red Sox, the relationship between Soto and his skipper appears to be in a different place. Mendoza told reporters that the team would speak with their star player about running harder out of the batter's box. Meanwhile, Soto claimed he has been "hustling pretty hard."
Juan Soto was asked about not hustling out of the box last night vs. the Yankees and tonight vs. the Red Sox
— SNY (@SNYtv) May 20, 2025
"I think I've been hustling pretty hard. If you see it today, you could tell" pic.twitter.com/vOmQivgtZR
The disconnect between player and coach is certainly not nothing, but questions about Soto's enthusiasm and effort would likely be smoothed over by Soto breaking out of his slump. The four-time All-Star continues to rank in the upper 90th percentile in nearly all of Baseball Savant's advanced batting metrics, including a top 4% average exit velocity (94.2 mph) and a top 6% hard hit rate (55.0%).
Sunday's finale was decided after a Yankees' six-run eighth inning that began on a Pete Alonso throwing error. In an attempt to replicate a nearly identical play from the game before, the first baseman air-mailed a throw home that allowed Jasson Dominguez to score and break the 2-2 tie.
In an attempt to cut down the go-ahead run in the eighth inning, Pete Alonso threw well wide of home plate. The Mets are down to their final three outs. pic.twitter.com/F5UGfiJLcj
— Anthony DiComo (@AnthonyDiComo) May 19, 2025
After the game, Alonso owned his error, saying he "just made an awful throw." The long-time Met went further: "the whole inning, the game, it's on me." New York's infield has struggled in big spots as of late and has committed 19 errors this season. When asked about the defensive woes, Mendoza admitted that his "good defenders" need to improve.
The first Subway Series with Soto in a Mets uniform is ultimately just three games in a long season. However, it's impossible to deny the magnitude of his return to Yankee Stadium and the ensuing media frenzy. The number one fix for Soto and the Amazin's will be to get the bats going and get back in the win column.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!