One Free Agent Relief Pitcher That Pirates Must Target

Abreu pitched the second-most innings, posted the sixth-best WAR (6.0), the ninth-lowest ERA and the 10th-highest K/9 of any reliever during that time.

His slider and four-seam fastball combo has resulted in him putting up some of the best whiff and strikeout rates of any pitcher in baseball.

Abreu worked with pitching coach Bill Murphy, then with the Astros, who took the same job with the Pirates ahead of the 2026 season.

He struggled in the first half of 2026, with a 5.81 ERA and a 1.68 WHIP, but bounced back in the second half with a 1.71 ERA and a 1.04 WHIP.

Murphy could play a big role in helping Abreu become the dominant pitcher he once was and make him a big part of a strong Pirates bullpen.

Where Abreu Would Fit in Pirates' Bullpen

Abreu has primarily pitched as a setup man in his career and would serve as an important right-handed high-leverage arm.

The Pirates added Luke Weaver at the trade deadline, and he should assume the setup role next season, but having another option is always important.

Abreu pitched earlier than the seventh inning once for the Astros in 2026 and hasn't consistently pitched before the seventh inning since 2022.

The Pirates have three right-handed pitchers who should assume more middle reliever/bulk roles in Lake Bachar, Carmen Mlodzinski and Yohan Ramírez.

Abreu would join Weaver and shutdown closer, left-handed Mason Montgomery, as the three best high-leverage options for the Pirates in 2027, barring any other additions.

Would Pirates Sign Abreu?

Abreu does have some concerns, as would any pitcher, such as an incredibly high walk rate and allowing high hard-hit rates.

The Pirates need more bullpen help for next season, and they can't make the mistake of last offseason, when they didn't add enough.

Abreu has some reasonable contract projections, with The Athletic and ESPN both putting him at one year, $10.5 million and MLB Trade Rumors putting him at two years, $22 million ($11 million AAV).

It's a number the Pirates need to reach if they want to sign veteran relievers and for what Abreu has done and achieved under Murphy, it makes a lot of sense.

The Pirates will almost certainly set a record for Opening Day payroll, with the current projection at $100 million before any additional moves, and they need to sign players like Abreu, who will help them reach the postseason for the first time since 2015.