
Much has been made about Baltimore Orioles catcher Adley Rutschman's regression on offense over the past two seasons. In 2023, Rutschman produced a .277 average and an .809 OPS, which was the second-best OPS out of qualified catchers in the MLB that season (only behind the .824 OPS that William Contreras produced with the Milwaukee Brewers).
Then Rutschman's OPS declined by a whopping 100 points in 2024, going from .809 to .709. This was a seismic drop, and took Rutschman's OPS from being second-best among all qualified catchers in 2023 to ninth-best in 2024, and sixth among AL catchers.
This regression has continued in 2025. Rutschman currently has a .224 average and a .676 OPS in 86 games played this season. Out of every MLB catcher who has played in a game this season, 41 of them have a better 2025 OPS than Rutschman.
However, Rutschman's impact isn't solely felt at the plate. What he does behind the plate is equally (if not more) important, given how crucial a catcher is for anchoring a team's defense.
The advanced stats show that Rutschman has been an above-average defensive catcher this season, according to Baseball Savant. His +2 Fielding Run Value puts him at the 67% percentile among his peers, and he's one of baseball's best framers.
This is a clear improvement from the 2024 season, where Rutschman's -1 Fielding Run Value was below average.
It seems that Orioles interim manager Tony Mansolino thinks highly of Rutschman's defense, which was conveyed by a recent comment he made that Andy Kostka of The Baltimore Banner put in a September 23 X post.
"In terms of calling the game, don’t undervalue the fact [Dean Kremer] just had such an efficient, clean outing the first day Adley’s back [from injury]. He has become a very good catcher in this league in understanding," Mansolino was quoted by Kostka as saying.
Tony Mansolino said Adley Rutschman's growth as a catcher has been significant.
— Andy Kostka (@afkostka) September 24, 2025
"In terms of calling the game, don’t undervalue the fact Deano just had such an efficient, clean outing the first day Adley’s back. He has become a very good catcher in this league in understanding."
Mansolino is touching on a vital point about assessing a catcher that doesn't show up on any stat: how good they can call a game and can keep their pitching staff under control throughout what can be a rollercoaster game.
Many catchers will say that learning how to navigate a staff that has different pitches, personalities, and preferences is the toughest part of the job. And Mansolino is giving Rutschman flying marks in that regard.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!