Yardbarker
Yardbarker
x
Pirates ownership reportedly intervened in past efforts to trade closer
Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images

The Pirates are a mess. They fired manager Derek Shelton after a 12-26 start and currently sit 11.5 games out of a playoff spot. Their situation is dire enough that fans and pundits alike have wondered whether they might trade Paul Skenes just 1.5 years into his big league career. That’s never seemed likely, and a Pirates official recently said there’s “no way” the team would consider that, but the fact that it even needs to be said speaks to the current status of the team.

Pittsburgh’s ongoing rebuild simply hasn’t worked as hoped. Trades of Starling Marte, Josh Bell, Adam Frazier, Joe Musgrove, Jameson Taillon, Richard Rodriguez and others haven’t netted nearly enough talent. Other possible trade chips have been held onto and seen their stock dwindle. One player who many have expected to be on that list of traded Pirates stars over the years is closer David Bednar, but he’s still in Pittsburgh and working to rebuild his stock after a poor 2024 season and after being optioned to Triple-A amid some early-2025 struggles.

Bednar may well have been traded by now, it seems, if were up to the front office alone. But Noah Hiles of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reports in his latest mailbag column that ownership has previously “stepped in” to prevent the baseball operations staff from trading him.

It’s not clear when a potential Bednar trade might’ve been coming together. He’s been the subject of rumors dating back to the 2022 season, when the Pirates reportedly rejected what at the time were described as “tempting” offers for both Bednar and outfielder Bryan Reynolds. Bednar’s name has been synonymous with each of the two subsequent trade deadlines as well, and he’ll surely be talked about again this summer. Hiles notes that he does not expect ownership intervention this time around — presumably a reflection on Bednar’s struggles over the past calendar year, his mounting price tag ($5.9MM in 2025) and his dwindling level of club control (through the 2026 season).

Ownership stepping in to meddle in baseball operations affairs is hardly a situation that’s unique to the Pirates. Over the years there have been various reports of Angels owner Arte Moreno going over his front office’s head in free agency and more recently of quashing a potential Shohei Ohtani trade late in his tenure with the team. Astros owner Jim Crane operated without a GM in place for months after former GM James Click’s ouster in Houston and signed Jose Abreu and Rafael Montero to regrettable free agent deals while serving as the de facto head of baseball operations. You can go all the way back to 2012 and find reports of Rockies owner Dick Monfort nixing a trade that would’ve sent Jorge De La Rosa from Colorado to Baltimore in exchange for then-prospect Eduardo Rodriguez.

Bednar likely holds some extra value in the eyes of Pirates chairman Bob Nutting and the rest of the ownership group. He’s a Pittsburgh native who grew up rooting for the Pirates and quickly became the most (and only) productive player acquired from the aforementioned trade of Musgrove. Those Pittsburgh roots presumably make Bednar a bit more marketable, although his hometown ties to the area were not expressly mentioned by Hiles as a reason for ownership’s intervention in those trade talks.

Regardless of the reason, it’s likely that prior ownership protest prevented GM Ben Cherington and his staff from capitalizing on Bednar closer to peak value. Bednar broke out as a top-notch setup man in 2021 and by 2022 had assumed the closer’s role in Pittsburgh. From 2022-23, he pitched 119 innings with a 2.27 ERA, 30.6% strikeout rate, 7.6% walk rate and 0.53 homers per nine frames — all while compiling 58 saves for a team that only won 138 games. A hearty 42% of the Pirates’ victories in that two-year period were nailed down by Bednar.

Back in 2022, Bednar would’ve come with four and a half more seasons of club control. In 2023, that’d have (obviously) been three and a half. The asking price for an All-Star closer in his pre-arb years would presumably have been substantial. By 2024, Bednar’s value had plummeted. He missed several weeks in the first half due to an oblique strain and lugged an unsightly 4.95 ERA into the trade deadline. If ownership stepped in to quash a trade at that point, it’d be a bit more understandable, as selling low on a pitcher as talented as Bednar understandably may not have been viewed favorably. Again, the timetable surrounding the events isn’t clear.

Whether due to ownership or lack of sufficient offers, Bednar stayed put last summer — and the Pirates are probably better off for it. It’s true that he struggled enough early on to briefly be optioned to Triple-A Indianapolis, but that brief reset looks to have done wonders. In 13 1/3 innings since returning, Bednar has posted a sharp 3.38 ERA with exceptional rate stats. He’s punched out 20 batters (37% of his total opponents) against just one walk (1.9%). His velocity is as strong as ever, with a fastball sitting 97.1 mph, and he’s inducing grounders at what would be a career-high 48.5% clip (way up from last year’s 37.1%).

If Bednar can continue anywhere close to that pace over the next month or two, he’ll be an in-demand asset once again. With the Pirates in a total state of collapse and Bednar only controlled through 2026, he’d seem like a very strong candidate to change hands this time around. That’s perhaps even truer given that from midseason 2024 through early 2025, it looked like the Pirates had missed their opportunity to trade him for anything of note at all.

This article first appeared on MLB Trade Rumors and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!

TODAY'S BEST

Brewers' Jacob Misiorowski continues to set radar gun on fire at unprecedented rate
MLB

Brewers' Jacob Misiorowski continues to set radar gun on fire at unprecedented rate

Milwaukee Brewers Jacob Misiorowski was back on the mound on Tuesday night against the Seattle Mariners, and even though he pitched just 3.2 innings, he continued to show why he is one of baseball's most exciting young talents. Prior to be pulled after 64 pitches, he allowed just three hits, walked one and struck out seven to continue his stunning start to his big league career. He also continued to light up the radar gun in a way that no other pitcher in the modern era has. Following Tuesday's start, where he regularly clocked in at over 101 mph, he has now thrown 39 pitches this season that have eclipsed 101 mph on the radar gun. He has done that in just 29.1 innings over six starts. By comparison, every other starting pitcher in Major League Baseball has tallied just 17 pitches of 101 mph or higher — combined. But it's not just about how he stacks up with pitchers this season that is staggering. It's that he is near the top of the list for 101 mph pitches for a career. Here are two of his 101 mph heaters from Tuesday. The ball just erupts out of his hand at the hitters. When you add in his mid-90s change-up and high-90s breaking pitches he is already one of the nastiest pitchers in the majors. It is that sort of electric stuff that made him a National League All-Star after just five appearances. For the season, he has now struck out 40 batters in 29.1 innings of work (that is 12.27 per nine innings), allowed only 15 hits and just eight earned runs. And five of those earned runs against came in only one start. Given his age and with the way teams today are extremely protective of their pitchers, he is probably going to see his pitch counts and innings closely monitored this season. When he is on the mound, though, he is quickly becoming appointment viewing.

Deion Sanders says he's not 'all the way recovered' amid health issue
College Football

Deion Sanders says he's not 'all the way recovered' amid health issue

It seems like it might be a little longer before Deion Sanders can join the rest of his Colorado coaching staff. In a video recently posted by his son, Deion Sanders Jr, the NFL legend admitted that he's not yet fully recovered from his undisclosed health issue. “You know I’m still going through something,” the head coach said. “I ain’t all the way recovered.” Almost two weeks ago, Sanders took the stage at Big 12 media day, but he didn't want to address his health issues. “I’m not here to talk about my health,” Sanders said. “I’m here to talk about my team.” According to the Athletic, Sanders, who's recovering in his home in Texas, has been in close contact with his coaching staff. Colorado athletic director Rick George also said that Sanders would "probably" report to campus within the next two weeks, per the Athletic. The former Super Bowl winner has a long history of health concerns. He had two toes amputated in 2021 because of blood clots, and he went under the knife again in 2023 after reportedly dealing with some excruciating pain. The Buffaloes are transitioning into the post-Shedeur Sanders/Travis Hunter era and looking to build from last year's 9-4 record and big win at the Alamo Bowl.

Packers’ Starter Could Be Shocking Roster Cut Later This Summer
NFL

Packers’ Starter Could Be Shocking Roster Cut Later This Summer

The Green Bay Packers have revamped the wide receiving corps over the offseason. In addition to selecting Matthew Golden in the first round of April’s NFL Draft, and rounding back to add Savion Williams in the third round, the Packers also inked veteran Mecole Hardman as a free agent, further bolstering Jordan Love’s supporting cast, creating competition and in all likelihood adding special teams value. Suddenly, the Packers’ crowded wide receiver room could be one of the hottest competitions for snaps and roster spots in the league. Could the Packers Move on From Christian Watson? Christian Watson is still recovering from a torn ACL, but not everyone believes he’s a lock to even make the Packers’ roster out of training camp. Pro Football Network’s Jacob Infante suggests Watson could be cut, or traded, at some point this summer. “Watson doesn’t have the special-teams value that Mecole Hardman,” Infante writes of Watson. “Bo Melton, and Malik Heath all have. Both Romeo Doubs and Dontayvion Wicks have done a better job of staying healthy, and Jayden Reed and the two rookies are locks to make the team. That could leave Watson as a realistic cut candidate since he is sidelined with a torn ACL.” Moving on from Watson would be a pretty big surprise, for the Packers, but not out of the realm of possibility. Through his first three seasons, Watson has caught 96 passes for 1,653 yards and 14 touchdowns, and if healthy, would likely begin this season at or near the top of the depth chart. He simply isn’t healthy and doesn’t contribute much on special teams. The Packers have established a youth movement and have certainly created competition at the position, and if Green Bay believes that the likes of Wicks, Reed, and Melton are more valuable than Watson, it could lead to some difficult conversations and decisions in the weeks ahead about the 26-year-old’s future.

Jaguars' Liam Coen gave Trevor Lawrence unique task early into training camp
NFL

Jaguars' Liam Coen gave Trevor Lawrence unique task early into training camp

It's no secret that one reason the Jacksonville Jaguars hired former Tampa Bay Buccaneers offensive coordinator Liam Coen as their new head coach is that those running the Jaguars believe Coen can help fifth-year quarterback Trevor Lawrence make a major leap in his development. While speaking with reporters at training camp on Wednesday, Lawrence discussed how he and other quarterbacks on the roster were given a timed, 100-question quiz regarding the offense when they reported for camp on July 19. "It was pretty difficult," Lawrence said about Coen's test, as shared by Michael DiRocco of ESPN. "Some of [the questions] were some layups, but, yes, there were some good questions in there, some tough ones that kind of get us back going for camp and get the mind going and all the stuff you have to do as a quarterback. It was good. It kind of encompassed our whole offense, whether it's scheme, protections, it was a lot of stuff that was good to do as one of our first days back to kind of make sure we're ready to go." Coen is the third full-time head coach Lawrence has had since the Jaguars made the 25-year-old the first pick of the 2021 NFL Draft. Buccaneers quarterback Baker Mayfield enjoyed the best campaign, to date, of his career while playing in Coen's offense last season, and the hope for Jacksonville is that Lawrence will prove to be a quick learner this summer. Lawrence said on Wednesday that he was responsible for "a couple bad answers" as he got 15 of the 100 questions wrong. He has plenty of time before the Jaguars open the regular season with a matchup versus the Carolina Panthers on Sept. 7 to ace Coen's quiz. While Lawrence signed a five-year contract extension worth up to $275M last offseason, he has been the subject of some trade rumors ever since he was shut down in early December to undergo shoulder surgery. He dealt with "general soreness" in his throwing arm back in June, but Juston Lewis of the Florida Times-Union noted that Lawrence insisted on Wednesday he's feeling "the best [he has] felt in a long time physically." Earlier in the summer, Lawrence acknowledged he knows he has to "really turn it on" following a disappointing 2024 season that the Jaguars ended with a record of 4-13. It sounds like Coen plans to have Lawrence hard at work through the end of the preseason.