Should the Yankees Consider Trading Jazz Chisholm Jr.?

Before the season, he declared his goal was to be the second player in MLB history to hit 50 homers and steal 50 bases. Instead, he entered the All-Star break with 13 home runs and 26 stolen bases. It’s going to be a hard feat to accomplish as he has been underwhelming this year.

So, is Chisholm worth $280 to $350 million? Not with the season he’s having so far.

Yankees Don’t Pay for Second Basemen

The position matters in this scenario. The Yankees don’t like to flex the checkbook for a second baseman.

They let Robinson Cano walk when he was the best second baseman in baseball instead of getting stuck in a decade-long contract. The Yankees don’t want to give out a Cano-type deal to a player who is built on athleticism. In five years, his speed and power may be shot. Plus, prior injury issues make it hard for the Yankees to warrant that much money to Chisholm.

They would rather build the position from within through young or veteran players. Cano started nine straight seasons at second; since his departure, the longest starter has been Gleyber Torres, who only started three straight seasons. The Yankees let him walk away as well — they simply don’t view it as a premium position.

This doesn’t mean the Yankees won’t go out and spend on a second baseman, but they won’t spend around $300 million on one. Chisholm brings an edge the Yankees have lacked, but his strikeouts and inconsistency mirror the team’s biggest flaws. With that, trading him may open up other opportunities to narrow down on these issues.

Moving Jazz Chisholm Could Fix Lineup Issues

The Yankees are built on power. Their formula is to outslug the competition, which works in the regular season, but fans have seen it fail during the postseason numerous times.

The Yankees struggled mightily to score last postseason against the Blue Jays, who were the complete opposite of them. They wore down pitchers by putting the ball in play and creating chaos on the basepaths. From top to bottom, the Yankee lineup strikes out a ton. They’re currently fifth in strikeouts and third in K%. Recently, they were the first American League team to strike out 17 times in back-to-back games.

This simply isn’t a winning formula come October.

Chisholm is a part of this problem. He currently has the most strikeouts among Yankee hitters and the second-most among all second basemen in baseball. While this approach got him the third 30-30 season in Yankees history, it prolongs offensive droughts such as the one the Yankees went on going into the break.

Trading Chisholm for roster depth such as a high-leverage reliever or catcher would now create a hole at second base. The Yankees could solve this internally by promoting their top prospect George Lombard Jr. and slide Jose Caballero to second, but another fit for the Yankees would solve multiple issues.

The Yankees could reshape their offense by going after one of baseball’s best pure hitters, Luis Arraez.

Why Yankees Trading for Luis Arraez Works

The San Francisco Giants look poised to be sellers come the deadline. There currently 19.5 games behind the Los Angeles Dodgers and 10.5 back from the final Wild Card spot. If they decide to move impending free agents, the three-time Batting Title winner, Luis Arraez, should be on the Yankees’ radar.

Unlike Chisholm, Arraez thrives on his elite bat-to-ball skills rather than his power. The 2026 All-Star is having one of the best seasons of his career. Arraez is hitting .330/.369/.460 with a wRC+ of 127. More importantly, he doesn’t strike out, as he holds the lowest strikeout rate among all qualified hitters at four percent. Arraez would give the Yankees the true leadoff hitter they’ve lacked for years.

The most surprising part of Arraez’s game this year has been his defense. He has transformed himself from a defensive liability into a top defender in baseball. His 99th percentile outs above average have made him much more valuable.

Trading Chisholm wouldn’t be an easy decision for the Yankees. There aren’t many second basemen of his caliber, but if the front office believes he isn’t a part of the team’s future, there is little reason not to trade him for upgrades in spots of need.

The Yankees don’t need Arraez to replace Chisholm’s homers and stolen bases. They need Arraez to consistently get on base and set the table for Aaron Judge and Ben Rice. It would make the lineup far more dangerous come the playoffs.