Yardbarker
Yardbarker
x
Top Landing Spots for Free Agent Carlos Santana
Matt Krohn-Imagn Images

Carlos Santana is a fascinating free agent. That’s not something you’d usually hear about a first baseman entering his age-39 season. Yet, Santana defies preconceptions.

He might be one of the oldest players in baseball, but he was excellent in 2024. According to FanGraphs WAR, he was one of the 35 most valuable position players in the American League. Among primary first basemen, in either league, his 3.0 fWAR ranked fifth.

Sanatana also defies the stereotypes about aging first basemen. He’s an excellent defensive player. The veteran has produced 36 Outs Above Average and 30 Defensive Runs Saved at first base over his career. He finally took home his first Gold Glove this fall.

With all that said, Santana isn’t going to sign a multi-year deal worth tens of millions of dollars this offseason. He’s not going to out-earn fellow first basemen Pete Alonso or Christian Walker – even though he outperformed them both in 2024, according to fWAR.

As a 38-year-old first baseman, Santana’s ceiling is limited. Moreover, there will always be a risk that his age will eventually catch up to him. Besides, it’s not as if he was the most consistent hitter in the years preceding his strong 2024 campaign.

For all those reasons, Santana is a fascinating free agent. If he can repeat his 2024 performance in 2025, his new team will get a huge boost. But that’s far from a guarantee.

Here are a few teams that could take a chance on Carlos Santana this winter.

Seattle Mariners

Santana was a member of the Mariners team that broke the franchise’s playoff drought in 2022. Perhaps he’s the secret to getting them back to the postseason in 2025.

Seattle has already been closely linked to the veteran first baseman this winter. According to Ryan Divish of The Seattle Times, they were willing to offer him a one-year contract during the Winter Meetings. Although no deal came together, Divish suggests the Mariners haven’t given up.

As much as the M’s might like Santana, it’s not clear if the interest is mutual. The team already has a potential first baseman, Luke Raley, and Santana might not like the idea of a platoon gig. As a switch-hitter and a Gold Glover, he is surely looking for a full-time first base job in 2025.

If the Mariners are willing to offer him that role, however, this might be the best match.

New York Yankees

The Yankees have been linked to all the top first basemen available this offseason, including Alonso, Walker, Santana, and Paul Goldschmidt, as well as trade candidates Cody Bellinger and Josh Naylor.

It’s not surprising the Yankees are big players in the first base market. Not only is their former first baseman, Anthony Rizzo, a free agent, but they’re looking for offense anywhere they can get it as they try to replace Juan Soto.

Santana might not be the first choice in New York – the Yankees would probably prefer a bigger bat. Still, there is little doubt this team is going to land somebody, and they could do a whole lot worse than Carlos Santana.

Minnesota Twins

The fit here is pretty obvious. The Twins need a new first baseman after losing Santana to free agency. Santana is coming off a terrific season with the Twins. He hit especially well at Target Field (126 wRC+). Is there a reunion in the cards?

For what it’s worth, Bobby Nightengale of The Minnesota Star Tribune wrote that the Twins were still interested in Santana last week. As for Santana, he might like the stability of returning to Minnesota for a second season; he switched uniforms four times between 2022 and ’24.

Detroit Tigers

Santana has already played for the Guardians, Royals, and Twins. Why not add a fourth AL Central team to the mix?

The Tigers have made it clear that Spencer Torkelson’s spot in the lineup won’t be guaranteed in 2025. The former top prospect has struggled to generate consistent offense over three big league seasons.

If this team is serious about contending in 2025, it might be time to opt for a more reliable first baseman.

Truthfully, the Tigers could use a bigger upgrade for the offense than Santana. However, it seems like president of baseball operations Scott Harris might be operating with a limited budget this winter. If he isn’t able to give out a multi-year commitment, Santana might be his guy.

The Tigers haven’t been formally linked to Santana yet this offseason, but they have reportedly shown interest in Paul Goldschmidt. It’s not hard to imagine Harris pivoting to Santana if Goldschmidt signs elsewhere.

Washington Nationals

The Nationals didn’t have a regular first baseman in 2024, and it showed. Collectively, their first basemen produced a 93 wRC+ and just 0.3 fWAR.

Right now, Juan Yepez is the most likely candidate to start at first base for Washington in 2025. Yepez is coming off a perfectly respectable season (113 wRC+ in 62 games), but he’ll be 27 next year, and he’s far from a proven big league regular.

The Nationals could easily slide Yepez into a part-time DH role, freeing up first base for Santana.

So, why would Santana be interested in Washington? He might like the idea of being the veteran mentor to a young lineup.

In a best-case scenario, he could help the Nationals make a surprising Wild Card run. Otherwise, he’d be a prime candidate for a trade deadline swap to a contender. Santana is no stranger to a midseason trade, having been dealt ahead of the deadline in 2022 and ’23.

More Possible Landing Spots for Carlos Santana

Houston Astros

Houston needs a first baseman to replace José Abreu. Walker has long seemed like a possibility, but GM Dana Brown is very unlikely to sign Walker if he also re-signs Alex Bregman.

If the Astros re-sign Bregman, Carlos Santana could be the ideal target to cure their first base woes on a budget.

Arizona Diamondbacks

If the Diamondbacks can’t re-sign their Gold Glove first baseman, perhaps they go for the discount version instead. Surely the D-backs would love to have Christian Walker back, but Santana could be their backup plan.

New York Mets

The Mets are another team that lost their beloved first baseman to free agency. It certainly seems like they’ll try to bring him back, but if he goes elsewhere, you have to think Steve Cohen is going to shell out for a different All-Star to man first base.

This article first appeared on Just Baseball and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!

TODAY'S BEST

ESPN Predicts Mets-Twins Trade One Week Before Deadline
MLB

ESPN Predicts Mets-Twins Trade One Week Before Deadline

The New York Mets are a half-game ahead of the Philadelphia Phillies for first place in the NL East, but their pitching staff is still injury-ravaged despite the recent returns of Sean Manaea and Frankie Montas. Brandon Waddell (hip), Dedniel Nuñez (elbow), Max Kranick (flexor), Paul Blackburn (shoulder), Tylor Megill (elbow), Griffin Canning (Achilles), Drew Smith (elbow), A.J. Minter (lat), Danny Young (elbow), and Christian Scott (elbow) are alll on the Mets' IL. The MLB Trade Deadline is July 31 at 6 p.m. EST, so the front office has one week to add healthy arms from around the league this season. ESPN's David Schoenfield predicted on Thursday that New York would trade for a Minnesota Twins reliever. "One guarantee of the trade deadline: The Mets will add to the bullpen, probably with more than one trade. Though the rotation still ranks fifth in ERA, that was built off a hot start," he wrote. "More importantly, the only Mets starter to complete six innings since June 7 has been David Peterson. As a result, manager Carlos Mendoza has run relievers Reed Garrett, Huascar Brazoban, Jose Butto and Ryne Stanek into the ground. The bullpen had a 2.78 ERA through May, but that figure is over 5.00 since the beginning of June (ranking near the bottom of the majors)." "The Twins have two high-profile relievers in [Jhoan] Duran and [Griffin] Jax, both of whom are under team control through 2027, so they'll be much more expensive than your usual short-term relievers if the Twins decide to trade one or both," he continued. "Duran would be harder to deal -- but bring more in return -- so we'll say Jax will go. Don't be fooled by his 4.09 ERA: He has 68 strikeouts and 12 walks in 44 innings with a 97-mph heater. He's an elite strikeout reliever, the type you want on the mound in October." The Mets are hot despite their injuries, as they're on a four-game winning streak and just swept the Los Angeles Angels. Next up is a road trip against the San Francisco Giants and San Diego Padres. New York right-handed pitcher Clay Holmes (8-5, 3.48 ERA) will face Giants right-hander Logan Webb (9-7, 3.08 ERA) on Friday.

‘In What World Does This Make Sense?????’: Oilers and $63M Forward
NHL

‘In What World Does This Make Sense?????’: Oilers and $63M Forward

According to some, throw out the idea that the Edmonton Oilers should pursue Max Pacioretty. A veteran forward who has earned over $63 million over the course of his NHL career has yet to sign an NHL contract and was recently mentioned in a post by David Staples as a possible fit. In a recent post, the Journal noted, “All of the top NHL unrestricted free agents have already signed contracts, but there’s one big name player still available that makes good sense for the Edmonton Oilers to pursue.” Responses have been varied, with a few quite vocal about the Oilers not following Staples’ advice. “In what world does this make sense?????” writes a commenter on a recent post for The Hockey Writers. Another commenter wrote, “Pacioretty is a good journeyman player but he is injury prone now, late in his career. Oilers might be lucky to get 40 games out of him. They should look elsewhere instead of taking a chance on Patches.” Tyler Yaremchuk of Oilers Nation chimed in and said, “He scored five goals in 37 games last year with the Toronto Maple Leafs. Can’t stay healthy, very old, very slow.” Yaremchuk then went on a rant, listing several Oilers forwards who would be better than Pacioretty. What About Pacioretty on a PTO? Is there any reason that a team that is looking to get younger and faster, and move out depth pieces that were older and less productive than expected, would revert back to last summer’s strategy? It seems like an odd choice on the surface. Something would have to happen that would make giving Pacioretty a look risk-free. That means only a PTO. Even at that point, should he agree, it would require him to be willing to sign a two-way contract for the league minimum.

Bengals finally reach agreement with first-rounder Shemar Stewart
NFL

Bengals finally reach agreement with first-rounder Shemar Stewart

The Cincinnati Bengals have finally reached an agreement with first-round pick Shemar Stewart, putting an end to what became the story of the offseason for the team. Stewart, drafted 17th overall in this year's draft, has finally agreed to a four-year, fully guaranteed $18.97 million deal that includes a $10.4 million signing bonus, according to his agent Zac Hiller of LAA. Now with this deal done, every first-round pick is signed. The road to this deal was a bumpy ride. For months, negotiations between Stewart’s camp and the Bengals front office stalled due to disagreements over contract language, particularly around guarantees. The team pushed to include contract language that could void the deal under certain off-field circumstances, but since other Bengals first-round picks did not face similar terms, Stewart stood firm and refused to sign. Both sides remained firm throughout the offseason, leading to a long standoff and a lot of reports of frustration from both sides. Despite the frustration and disagreement, the Bengals and Stewart’s group continued to engage in conversations, trying to find a resolution to the issue. And finally, after weeks of back and forth and weeks of controversy surrounding what Stewart may be forced to do, both parties appear to have met in the middle and found common ground. For the Bengals, getting Stewart signed and ready for training camp is a major win. Stewart was viewed as a developmental prospect who needed plenty of on-field reps to reach his full potential. Stewart's absence from earlier camps had slowed a lot of his progress. With the contract dispute resolved, he can now focus entirely on gaining important reps and continuing his development over the coming weeks. Now with this contract done and over with, the team can put their full focus on Trey Hendrickson, who is also seeking a long term deal. If the Bengals can get a deal done with Trey before the season kicks off, they would secure their edge-rushing room for not only 2025, but for years beyond. For a team looking to go all in on making the playoffs, signing Stewart was long overdue. Now it will be vital for the team to get Stewart up to speed with the rest of the roster, and allow him to get as many reps as possible before the 2025 season begins.

Davante Adams discusses time with Jets, Aaron Rodgers reunion
NFL

Davante Adams discusses time with Jets, Aaron Rodgers reunion

The reunion between quarterback Aaron Rodgers and wide receiver Davante Adams in 2024 was brief. After nearly two and a half years apart, the longtime Green Bay Packers duo attempted to rekindle their connection with the New York Jets. Adams worked his way to the Jets early in the 2024 season, dealt from the Las Vegas Raiders in exchange for a third-round pick in October. While the chemistry between them wasn't bad, the results spoke otherwise, as everything spiraled out of control in New York, ending in a 5-12 season. The star receiver was released by the club in March before joining the Los Angeles Rams in free agency, while Rodgers was handed the same fate, signing with the Pittsburgh Steelers in June. Adams was asked about Rodgers being his opponent again during an appearance on the "Up and Adams" show on Friday. “Aaron’s got to be happy. I mean, I’m happy for him. We both, we got to try it again together and gave that another shot. That stone wasn’t left unturned; we did what we had to do, and it just obviously didn’t work. Just like for me, I wish him nothing but luck, and I know he’s going to go out there and ball out too,” Adams said. Adams wound up amassing 67 receptions, 854 yards and seven touchdowns in 11 games as a Jet with Rodgers, per ESPN stats, averaging 77.6 yards per game, much higher than his previous season in Las Vegas. Two of the legendary quarterback's four NFL MVPs were won with Adams being his top target from 2020 to 2022. At their best, they were borderline unstoppable, though postseason shortcomings haunted them in the end. There's no doubting how good a QB-WR duo these two were in Green Bay; however, all that occurred in New York made it obvious that a change was necessary. The Rodgers-led Steelers and Adams and the Rams will have plenty of eyeballs on them in 2025. Unfortunately for fans, the two teams don't play each other this season... unless they find a way to meet up in San Francisco for Super Bowl LX in February.