Trevor Story Undergoes Hernia Surgery

The Red Sox announced that shortstop Trevor Story has undergone surgery to address a sports hernia. He was placed on the 10-day injured list last week. The Sox didn’t announce a timeline in today’s announcement but reporting from last week indicated Story was considering a surgery that would sideline him for six to ten weeks.

Story got out to an awful start this year, hitting .206/.244/.303 through 41 games before hitting the IL. After landing on the shelf, he told reporters that he had been dealing with discomfort since spring training, which perhaps contributed to his poor results. Ideally, the surgery will correct the issue and he can get back on track in the second half of the season.

Injuries have played a huge role in his time with the Red Sox. He and the club signed a six-year, $140MM deal going into the 2022 season. He only played 163 games over the first three years of that deal, missing time due to various issues, most notably internal brace surgery on his throwing elbow.

He was able to stay healthy last year and had a mostly good season, getting into 157 games. His walk and strikeout rates weren’t strong and he got poor grades for his glovework but he hit 25 home runs and stole 31 bases. Unfortunately, he couldn’t keep it rolling into 2026. As mentioned, he got out to a poor start and is probably going to be out of action until the All-Star break, give or take.

For now, the Sox will have to cover shortstop without Story. In the past week, most of the playing time has gone to Andruw Monasterio. He is hitting .250/.294/.388 with poor defensive grades, though in a small sample of just 70 innings at short.

Second baseman Marcelo Mayer has said that he would like a shot at moving across the bag. He came up as a shortstop prospect but moved over to second in deference to Story. Manager Chad Tracy seemed open to the idea but only if Story was going to miss significant time. If Story were only going to miss a week or two, then the plan would have been to keep Mayer at second to continue getting accustomed to that position.

Now that Story is likely going to be out for a while, perhaps Mayer will get his shot at shortstop, but there are no guarantees that will be good for the club. Mayer’s second base defense has been slightly above average this year but he’s only hitting .221/.290/.313, a worse line than Monasterio. Perhaps Mayer is capable of more, since he was a notable prospect and hit .271/.347/.471 in Triple-A last year, but he hasn’t clicked in the majors yet.

If Mayer is going to cover short, the Sox would then have to have someone at second. That could be Monasterio but Nick Sogard and Isiah Kiner-Falefa would be other options. Sogard is currently taking a good amount of playing time from the struggling Caleb Durbin at third. Kiner-Falefa is only hitting .255/.314/.277 this year but has a strong defensive track record.