x
Why Mattingly is the perfect manager to get the most out of Phillies
Philadelphia Phillies interim manager Don Mattingly. Dale Zanine-Imagn Images

Why Don Mattingly is the perfect manager to get the most out of Phillies

A 9-19 start to the 2026 season has led to the Philadelphia Phillies firing manager Rob Thomson on Tuesday. While some can argue if it's fair to blame Thomson for an underperforming roster, there's now a more important question that needs answered.  

Can interim skipper Don Mattingly save the Phillies' season? With 134 games left in Philadelphia's season, there's still plenty of time to turn things around and get back in the race.  

Mattingly also seems like the perfect option to try to inject new life into a team facing pressure to compete for a championship and get back to where Thomson had the franchise in his first season on the job in 2022, falling in the World Series to the Houston Astros. 

Don Mattingly was credited in helping the Blue Jays get to the World Series 

Though he hasn't been a manager since departing the Miami Marlins after the 2022 season, Mattingly has a long history of getting the most out of his players. He was even recently credited with helping Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and others take their games to another level throughout his three seasons as the Toronto Blue Jays' bench coach, culminating in winning the American League pennant in 2025. 

Mattingly's past as a former star player — he hit .307 across 14 seasons as the New York Yankees' first baseman from 1982-95, winning the 1985 AL MVP Award — provides him the helpful cache when working with top-level talent like Bryce Harper and Kyle Schwarber.

Don Mattingly is the perfect fit to help both the Phillies offense and defense

His knack for hitting makes him the perfect new voice and teacher for a Phillies team that's collectively hitting only .219, the second-lowest team batting average in MLB. Even Schwarber, who blasted 56 home runs last season, has cratered to become a feast-or-famine type of slugger with a pedestrian .196 average through 102 at-bats. 

In terms of a regularly used player with at least 90 at-bats, only left fielder Brandon Marsh is hitting above .263 at .297. If Mattingly can't bring out more from the lineup, the odds of anyone else being able to are slim. 

Beyond what Mattingly could offer the Phillies offense, he won nine Gold Gloves at first base as a player, making him an asset to Harper as he attempts to perfect the defensive side of the position. 

Don Mattingly has proven he can win as a manager 

Most importantly, Mattingly has a history of winning as a manger, at least when leading a worthy roster. His Marlins tenure was mostly a failure with only one postseason appearance in seven seasons, but his rosters weren't blessed with the star power he will now have in Philadelphia. 

When working with a quality roster, Mattingly led the Los Angeles Dodgers to three straight National League West Division titles in a pre-Shohei Ohtani era that saw the Dodgers struggle before his arrival in 2011. 

Getting a team out of the basement of a highly contested NL East won't be easy, but the 65-year-old Mattingly wouldn't have accepted this interim opportunity if he wasn't interested in giving it his best shot. And just as Mattingly is exactly what this Phillies team needs, they can help him re-prove himself as a manager all over again, too.

Mike J. Asti

Mike Asti is an experienced media personality and journalist with a vast resume and skillset, most notably from time with TribLIVE Radio and WPXI-TV. Asti now serves as the Managing Editor of WV Sports Now, where he leads the coverage of WVU sports. He has also covered the Steelers, Penguins, Pirates and other teams within the Pittsburgh market

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!