The San Diego Padres and Los Angeles Dodgers are division rivals; that much we know. However, the question that has recently caused a flurry is, does their rivalry run deeper?
Both teams had some prior history that included a bench-clearing brawl, but there didn’t seem to be anything that made one the arch-nemesis of the other.
Nonetheless, this Southern California tiff didn’t come into focus until last season. It started with a bench-clearing in April, and by mere fate, the two titans of the NL West would collide again in the NLDS.
In between innings during Game 2, Manny Machado, who got in a spat with Jack Flaherty after he hit Fernando Tatis Jr. with a pitch, threw a ball at his former manager, Dave Roberts. The Padres vehemently denied it was intentional, even barring Ken Rosenthal from their dugout because of his reporting on the matter. Still, the Dodgers were quick to note that the ball had some mustard on it.
That same game, Jurickson Profar robbed Mookie Betts of a home run, then made some new enemies by seemingly taunting Dodgers’ fans. Those same fans welcomed him back into the outfield by throwing stuff at him. The NLDS wound up falling in favor the Dodgers, something that wasn’t lost on San Diego.
Now, both teams have picked up where they left off. But if you ask any of the Dodgers, they don’t see it as an extension of their victorious NLDS; they just see it as a regular-season series. Dodgers’ third baseman, Max Muncy, doesn’t even see the Padres as rivals.
"The Padres bring everything that is in a rivalry, but you only have one rival," Muncy said on "Foul Territory." "I don't like when people say you have 'rivals.' I just think if you have a rival, it's your, you know, your counterpart, and that's always going to be the Giants. For the Dodgers, at least. It's always going to be the Red Sox for the Yankees.
"People always make the argument that the Astros and Yankees had a good rivalry going and it's like, that's true, but you only have one rival. And so, for me, like I said, the Padres bring everything that a rivalry brings. For me, your rival is just one team. You don't have multiple teams as your rival."
Max Muncy says the Giants will always be the Dodgers only rival.
— Foul Territory (@FoulTerritoryTV) June 9, 2025
"For me, your rival is just one team. You don't have multiple teams as your rival." pic.twitter.com/9az5E3QDmX
In a heartwarming gesture to Giants’ fans, Muncy legitimized San Francisco as a rival while brushing aside the notion that San Diego was equally rivalrous. Of course, Muncy has a personal stake in that rivalry.
During a game in San Francisco, Muncy hit a ball off Madison Bumgarner that splashed down in McCovey Cove. As Muncy watched, Bumgarner had some choice words. The conversation went like this:
“Don’t watch the ball! Run!” – Madison Bumgarner
"If you don't want me to watch the ball, you can get it out of the ocean." – Max Muncy
If anyone knows what it’s like to be a part of a rivalry, it’s Max Muncy. The Giants-Dodgers rivalry has existed for a long time, but Muncy stands as the current embodiment of this thrilling inter-California strife.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!