
Just five minutes into the New York Knicks' attempt at winning some revenge against Head Coach Mike Brown's former employer, the Sacramento Kings, Jalen Brunson appeared to tweak his ankle. The star scorer was held back from ever re-entering the game, one that his Knicks decisively dropped for their sixth loss over the course of their previous eight matchups.
Losing out on New York's star scorer wasn't ever projected to make the Knicks' job easier, but his sudden absence did offer a slight silver lining to evaluate throughout the near-future; he's been the clear-weakest link on a steadily-slipping defense, and the rest of the team had a clear shot at resetting without him in making the trip to visit the Golden State Warriors.
Instead, the unthinkable took place, and the defense somehow looked worse than ever. A second night of a back-to-back rarely makes for a sufficient sample to evaluate, but this loss was the most horrifying performance they've posted amidst a string of sloppy defensive outings.
In a 126-114 defeat, they allowed 134 points per 100 possessions. They were late on rotations and soft in one-on-one coverage, the exact same recipe that's repeatedly done them in as of recent. Over the Knicks' last nine games, a stretch in which they've come away with wins just twice, their 121.7 defensive rating has been the second-worst in the entire league. Opponents are getting easy shots against their defense and knocking them down with ease.
Even on their good days, the Knicks were dead-set on fortifying their defense from the inside-out. Anchor-big Mitchell Robinson and his quick rim-rotators were constantly sure to make life scoring at the basket especially difficult, but that left open shots around the perimeter for opponents to sting New York from outside.
Even before this nightmare-ish two-week span, the Knicks were in the bottom quarter of the NBA in opponent effective field goal percentage, which measures how players convert scoring opportunities both in-game and at the line by acknowledging some buckets as more valuable than others. It's no surprise, then, that those facing the Knicks are knocking down over 37% of their 3-point jumpers, the fourth-highest mark in the game on the sixth-most nightly attempts.
Look no further than the beating they took in Golden State, a game in which the band of good-not-great shooters on the Warriors rode the Knicks' "defense" to 20 long-range makes on 45 tries. That's a 44.4% success rate.
They were always a step behind in attempting to communicate as a team, stumbling on nearly every action that involved someone operating alongside screens. That issue was always going to be exposed when going against a one-of-one scorer like Stephen Curry, but they didn't seem to be in proper positioning against anyone that night.
If the Knicks being "soft" means that they struggled defending off-screens, sent help late when Jimmy Butler gets a switch or sent two and couldn't make up for it on the back end vs Steph, then yeah they were very soft last night pic.twitter.com/4OZVmuT8Eo
— Shax (@ShaxNBA) January 16, 2026
The constantly-open Warriors punished nearly every man defender who saw sufficient minutes for New York. Josh Hart held his ground, relatively speaking, and he still allowed over 44% of buckets that he directly contested to fall. Stunningly, that was the lowest of any Knicks starter; OG Anunoby couldn't escape the switching game in watching opponents shoot 9/13 on his watch, while 10 of the 11 attempts that Mikal Bridges tried to get in the way of eventually found nylon.
That's to say nothing of Karl-Anthony Towns, who's rightfully heard the lion's share of the coaching staff's ire during his stretch of ineffective, poorly-thought-through processing.
Games like this should be seen as an indictment of the Knicks defense; no contender should collapse this easily, especially with as many name-brand defenders as they have. This is a team-wide coordination issue, and it now falls on Brown to fix on the fly.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!