Basketball greatness often comes with a cabinet full of trophies. Yet, even for a player like LeBron James, whose accolades stretch nearly two decades, there remains one glaring omission: the Defensive Player of the Year award.
For someone who has dominated both ends of the court, the absence of this award is a source of frustration.
Throughout his career, LeBron has five NBA All-Defensive First Team selections, a testament to his defensive prowess. But the closest he came to clinching the coveted DPOY was in 2013, a season when his impact on the defensive side of the ball was undeniable. That year, the then-Miami Heat star finished second in the voting behind Marc Gasol, a decision that sparked heated debates.
Never forget when Bron got robbed of a perfect season in 2013.
— LeBron History (@bronhistory) May 26, 2023
The media gave the DPOY to Marc Gasol who didn’t even make 1st Team All-Defensive.
LeBron had 25 1st Team All-Defensive votes from the coaches. Gasol had 5. pic.twitter.com/UmDwh2jhQg
LBJ’s 2013 campaign is often remembered for his historic efficiency on offense, but his defensive impact was just as noteworthy. Anchoring a Miami Heat team that finished second in defensive rating that season, he was tasked with guarding every position on the floor. His versatility allowed Miami’s defense to flourish, whether shutting down speedy guards or contesting shots against big men.
Statistically, James was at his peak defensively. He averaged 1.7 steals and 0.9 blocks per game while playing 76 games in the regular season. He also posted a career-high defensive win share of 6.7, highlighting his ability to swing games with his defense. However, the Memphis Grizzlies center claimed the title when the votes were tallied. What made this result controversial was the peculiar voting dynamic.
“That’s the only award that I don’t have in my house that kind of stings,” LeBron said. “Like it doesn't make any sense; it doesn't make sense... The year I finished second in the Defensive Player of the Year Award, the guy who won Defensive Player of the Year didn’t even make First Team All-Defense.”
Gasol’s win was attributed mainly to his role in Memphis’s league-best defense that season, which revolved around his ability to protect the rim. Yet, the argument remains that James’s versatility, allowing him to guard multiple positions effectively, made him more deserving.
For many, the lack of a DPOY on LeBron’s resumé tilts comparisons with other all-time greats, particularly Michael Jordan. Widely regarded as one of the best defensive players in history, Jordan’s nine All-Defensive First Team appearances and three steals titles set him apart.
MJ’s defensive dominance was especially evident during the 1987-88 season when he averaged 3.2 steals and 1.6 blocks per game—mind-boggling numbers for a guard. That year, Jordan became the first player to win the DPOY and MVP in the same season, solidifying his two-way dominance.
On the other hand, King James has been on the brink of such achievements multiple times. Beyond the DPOY snub, another notable disappointment came in 2013, when he narrowly missed out on creating NBA history. James secured 120 of 121 first-place votes for MVP, with one voter choosing Carmelo Anthony instead. The omission was another reminder that even the best careers have moments of “what if?”
LeBron was 1 vote away from being the first unanimous MVP ever.
— LeBron History (@bronhistory) May 26, 2023
He got 129 of 130 first-place votes.
The 1 vote he didn’t get was from a reporter from Boston – the year after Bron ended their season in the ECF. https://t.co/aVRDLhqq44 pic.twitter.com/Kf77cNYD6P
LeBron’s defensive legacy is still celebrated, but the absence of that elusive DPOY award remains a lingering question. In the eyes of some, his career achievements are just short of perfection.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!