Yardbarker
Yardbarker
x
3 Observations on the Jaguars Trading Star Defender
Sep 24, 2023; Jacksonville, Florida, USA; Jacksonville Jaguars defensive lineman Roy Robertson-Harris (95) runs out of the tunnel before the game against the Houston Texans at EverBank Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Morgan Tencza-Imagn Images Morgan Tencza-Imagn Images

The Jacksonville Jaguars made big waves on Monday evening, trading former defensive captain and starting defensive lineman Roy Robertson-Harris for a 2026 sixth-round pick.

What does the Robertson-Harris trade mean for the Jaguars in the short- and long-term, and where do the Jaguars go from here? We break it down below.

The Robertson-Harris extension was simply poorly timed

A lot of social media jabs have been thrown to general manager Trent Baalke in the wake of the Robertson-Harris trade, and it makes sense why. Robertson-Harris was extended after the 2022 season seemingly due to a small sample size of impressive games at the end of the season. There was no real reason to make him an early extension candidate.

With that said, Baalke and the Jaguars could not have envisioned the team changing their entire defensive staff and scheme a year after the extension. Robertson-Harris has been a square peg in a round hole in Ryan Nielsen's scheme, but he was a good fit in Mike Caldwell's defense. The extension was never a good move, but the timing of the scheme change makes it look even worse.

Was this what Doug Pederson was referencing in terms of changing the culture?

Doug Pederson didn't mince words when talking about the team's culture after Sunday's loss to the Bears. In short, the Jaguars are currently a culture that is defined by losing. They have folded in five games this season -- three one-score games and two blowout losses where the Jaguars rolled over early in the game.

Could this be an example of what Pederson was talking about, or is it simply about the Jaguars putting up a 'for sale' sign in their front yard when it comes to trades? This type of move coming so shortly after Pederson's comments does make one raise eyebrows, and the truth is the answer is likely somewhere near the middle.

Why this move makes sense now

The biggest reason this move makes sense for the Jaguars? Because Robertson-Harris was never likely to be in the Jaguars' plans past 2024. Out of all of the returning defenders, it always seemed like his transition to Ryan Nielsen's defense would be the toughest. They were moving from a five-man front to a four-man front, which meant fewer snaps. Then the Jaguars added Arik Armstead and Maason Smith, which means even fewer snaps.

Robertson-Harris was having a solid season numbers-wise compared to his usual 17-game sample sies, but he is not somebody who was going to return in 2024 no matter what happens to the coaching staff on the defensive side of the ball. He was just an odd-man out from the jump, so getting any kind of return on him when you were going to release him for the same dead cap figure makes plenty of sense.

Ensure you follow on X (Twitter) @JaguarsOnSI and @_John_Shipley and never miss another breaking news story again.

Please let us know your thoughts when you like our Facebook page WHEN YOU CLICK RIGHT HERE


This article first appeared on Jacksonville Jaguars on SI and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!

TODAY'S BEST

Texans releasing former Pro Bowl OL
NFL

Texans releasing former Pro Bowl OL

Amid a full-scale offensive line makeover, the Texans are set to move on from a player they took a flier on this offseason. They are releasing Trent Brown, ESPN’s Adam Schefter reports. The 10-year veteran spent the summer on Houston’s active/PUP list, having suffered a torn patellar tendon during what amounted to a brief cameo in Cincinnati. The Texans needed to either activate Brown or send him to the reserve/PUP list. Option C, however, will be used. This will be the first time a team has released Brown. This release comes as Brown was moving toward a recovery from knee surgery, according to Wilson. But he will head back to free agency instead. The 380-plus-pound blocker having suffered a major knee injury during an age-31 season invited questions about his future, but a reunion with Nick Caserio — a Patriots exec when the team traded for Brown in 2018 — provided a lifeline. The Texans gave Brown a one-year, $2.35M deal with $550K guaranteed. Houston will eat only the $550K in dead money. Brown being nearly recovered is certainly notable, as it could lead to another chance given his history as a starter. Brown has made 96 starts, including three to open last season with the Bengals. Brown had spent the previous three years back in New England, after Las Vegas conducted an O-line makeover in 2021 that involved shedding a big-ticket Brown contract. Brown did not live up to the Raiders deal but became a regular again with the Patriots, starting at both LT and RT during his second stint. Brown has been injury-prone throughout his career, and although the former 49ers seventh-round pick operated as the Pats’ full-time LT during their 2018 Super Bowl-winning season, he has played more than 11 games just once since. The Texans also added two more tackles — Cam Robinson, Aireontae Ersery — this offseason. Robinson has emerged as a trade candidate. With Brown out of the picture, Ersery is moving toward the starting LT job (opposite the versatile Tytus Howard) with 2024 second-rounder Blake Fisher then set to be a swing tackle.

Dolphins agree to deal with one-time Super Bowl champ
NFL

Dolphins agree to deal with one-time Super Bowl champ

Frequent communication between Rasul Douglas and the Miami Dolphins has produced a deal. The veteran cornerback is headed to Miami on a one-year contract, Ian Rapoport of NFL Network reports. This pact is worth $3M, Rapoport adds. A notable role in the secondary should await Douglas upon arrival, despite the timing of this agreement. Cornerback has been an area of need all offseason, and the Dolphins somewhat surprisingly cut Mike Hilton on Monday. Hilton expected to wind up in Miami this offseason, but after arriving, he did not spend much time practicing with the starting defense. His release came about after Kendall Fuller was cut in the spring, a move that was eventually followed by the Jalen Ramsey trade. Kader Kohou and Artie Burns have since suffered season-ending injuries, leading to increased concern about the secondary for 2025. Douglas will aim to provide Miami with a veteran starting presence over the coming campaign. The soon-to-be 30-year-old has been on the Dolphins’ radar for much of the offseason, so this agreement comes as little surprise. Douglas was dealt from the Packers to the Bills midway through the 2023 campaign, and he handled starting duties with Buffalo. No new Bills accord was worked out, however, and Douglas made it known earlier this offseason that he did not foresee a return to Green Bay. Those factors pointed further to a Miami accord being worked out at some point, and with training camp and the preseason now finished, that has proven to be the case. Douglas has 80 starts and 120 appearances to his name, and he totaled 14 interceptions from 2021 to 2023. He was held without a pick last season, but the Dolphins would welcome a return to form from the former third-rounder. A strong campaign would help Miami’s defense for 2025 while also preventing a free agent from staying deep into August next offseason.

Key Darian Kinnard Trait Drew Packers to Trade for Super Bowl Winner
General Sports

Key Darian Kinnard Trait Drew Packers to Trade for Super Bowl Winner

Darien Kinnard has won a Super Bowl each of the past three seasons, but that isn’t the only reason the Packers acquired the veteran offensive lineman in a trade with the Philadelphia Eagles this past weekend. While general manager Brian Gutekunst, head coach Matt LaFleur, and the Packers obviously would love to see Kinnard’s streak continue with the Lombardi Trophy returning to Green Bay, it was a key trait that sparked the trade. Kinnard’s versatility was a major drawing card for Green Bay, according to Packers reporter Mike Spofford. “Typical of offensive line prospects who interest the Packers,” Spofford writes, for the team’s official website. “Kinnard can play multiple positions. In the recently completed preseason with the Eagles, he played both right guard and right tackle, with more snaps coming at guard. “He also took some snaps at left guard in practice, according to media reports out of Philadelphia.” Kinnard’s versatility gives the Packers the chance to add quality depth across multiple positions, including as an insurance policy if Rasheed Walker or Jordan Morgan fail to perform at a high level at right tackle in the weeks ahead. The 25-year-old played 68 snas at right tackle last season and only allowed one sack, so perhaps the Packers believe he’s capable of providing some stability, when needed, during the upcoming season and beyond.

Jets center sends warning to NFL about Justin Fields ahead of 2025 season
NFL

Jets center sends warning to NFL about Justin Fields ahead of 2025 season

Before quarterback Justin Fields, center Josh Myers and wide receiver Garrett Wilson began sharing the New York Jets' locker room this year, they were previously teammates at Ohio State. Myers is among those associated with the Jets who believe Fields will silence doubters when the games begin to matter next month. "I think there's definitely a chip on his shoulder," Myers recently said about Fields, as shared by Rich Cimini of ESPN. "Every time we've had a day that wasn't to our standard, he called out the whole offense, including himself. When we have those days, he lets everyone know about it." Two teams have given up on Fields since the Chicago Bears made him the 11th overall pick of the 2021 NFL Draft. He went 10-28 as a starter during his Bears tenure before the club decided to replace him with Caleb Williams via the first overall selection of the 2024 draft. Fields then lost a competition for the Pittsburgh Steelers' starting job to Russell Wilson last summer, but Fields entered the 2024 season as Pittsburgh's QB1 after Wilson went down with a calf problem. Fields guided Pittsburgh to a 4-2 record but nevertheless was benched in favor of Wilson from Week 7 through the Steelers' wild-card playoff loss to the Baltimore Ravens. It now seems that Pittsburgh head coach Mike Tomlin viewed future Hall of Famer Aaron Rodgers as an upgrade at the position before Fields reached free agency this past March. Fields signed a two-year contract to join the Jets, but the club can escape that deal as soon as next offseason. The fact that he reportedly "had an uneven training camp" has some Gang Green supporters fearing that he hasn't improved as a passer after he completed 60.3% of his pass attempts while with the Bears. "He can be an accurate passer when his feet are set and his weight is balanced," an unnamed scout said about Fields while speaking with Cimini. "When he doesn't have that, he's all over the place." Perhaps the alleged "chip on his shoulder" will help Fields enjoy a positive revenge-game performance when the Jets open the upcoming season with a home game against none other than the Steelers on Sept. 7.