49ers insider addresses Trent Williams release vs. trade debate

Shortly before San Francisco 49ers general manager John Lynch was scheduled to speak at the NFL Scouting Combine in Indianapolis, ESPN insider Adam Schefter reported that the team is in a contract standoff with star left tackle Trent Williams. Schefter suggested the situation could escalate to the point where the 49ers might release Williams if the two sides can't come to an agreement.

Naturally, Lynch was asked about the contract situation with Williams, and had an optimistic response.

"Well, what I'll tell you is that, in recent weeks, I've met with both Trent and with his agent, Vincent Taylor, and had really good, productive, and substantive meetings," Lynch said. "And so, here's what I know: Trent loves being a Niner. We love having Trent as a Niner. And it's up to us to figure that out, and to thread that needle."

Williams is scheduled to count nearly $39 million against the 49ers' salary cap in 2026, a figure Lynch and the team would likely love to reduce. While the future Hall of Fame offensive tackle remains one of the NFL's premier linemen, Lynch acknowledged there are "unique circumstances" surrounding the situation, including Williams' age.

"He's gonna be 38 years old, and so, there's some things that go into that," Lynch said, "but I think we're all on the same page, and I feel very positive about where that's going."

Schefter's note that the 49ers could release Williams if the two sides don't bridge their differences has sparked discussion. Why would the team take that action instead of pursuing a trade?

NBC Sports Bay Area insider Matt Maiocco addressed that debate during an appearance on KNBR. He believes a trade would make more sense, especially if the 49ers can get something noteworthy for one of the best players in football.

However, not every team with a need at tackle would be eager to make such a move.

"I would think that, for teams out there interested in him, they would realize that they would have to also — if they give the 49ers, say, a first-round draft pick for Trent Williams, or a second and a third, or whatever the case may be — they also have to meet his contract demands," Maiocco explained. "And so, there might be a little bit of reluctance for teams like that."

Committing draft capital and significant financial resources to an aging player will give some teams pause and could limit the trade market.

Still, for a contender with a glaring need at left tackle, the investment might be justified. Maiocco pointed to the New England Patriots, who clearly could have used someone like Williams in the Super Bowl against the Seattle Seahawks.

"So, yeah, there would be plenty of teams, I would think, that could feel like they could use Trent Williams in their starting lineup," Maiocco added.

It's also possible that Williams and the 49ers reach an agreement, allowing the veteran offensive lineman to finish his illustrious career in the Bay Area. A resolution is likely in the coming weeks, before Williams is due a $10 million option bonus.

Listen: Click here to listen on Omny.fm