Mike McCarthy might not have gotten the Dallas Cowboys over the hump they've been battling for three decades but his offense was highly productive at times.
Take the 2023 NFL season as an example. Dak Prescott and CeeDee Lamb both received All-Pro honors. His quarterback finished second in MVP voting and his wide receiver was in the mix for Offensive Player of the Year.
But one thing McCarthy's offense never did during his five-year tenure in Dallas was produce two 1,000-yard receivers in the same season. In fact, the last time that happened for the Cowboys was in 2019 with Amari Cooper and Michael Gallup, per Blogging the Boys' Editor-in-Chief RJ Ochoa.
There are 7 instances in Dallas Cowboys franchise history of multiple players having 1,000 receiving yards in a season:
— RJ Ochoa (@rjochoa) May 20, 2025
1979: Pearson/Hill
2006: Owens/Glenn
2007: Owens/Witten
2009: Austin/Witten
2010: Austin/Witten
2012: Bryant/Witten
2019: Cooper/Gallup
We will see if CeeDee…
It's safe to say, Brian Schottenheimer's offense is already better positioned to achieve that mark in Year 1 than McCarthy's ever was. That has more to do with the Cowboys wide receiver room than coaching itself, however. Throughout most of Lamb's career in Dallas, there hasn't been a consistent No. 2 wide receiver backing him up.
In 2025, that's changing with the presence of George Pickens, who Lamb sees as more than a No. 2.
"Oh no, we both ones," Lamb said last weekend. "It ain't no A/B, none of that, it's one, you look over there you see one, you look over here, you see another one. So do what you gotta do with that."
In three years at Pittsburgh, Pickens crossed the 1,000-yard mark once (2023). As a rookie, he logged 801 yards and 900 last year. But context is important: Justin Fields, Kenny Pickett, and the 2024 version of Russell Wilson were throwing the ball for those offenses and the overall scheme didn't help him a lot. Not to mention, he didn't receive plenty of relief from the rest of the pass catchers on the team.
In Dallas, Pickens is walking into the best situation he's been a part of at the NFL level. Dak Prescott represents a significant QB upgrade for him and he will have Lamb pulling coverage away, which should help him find one-on-one situations, where he excels at making contested catches.
Multiple 1,000-yard receivers should be expected from the Cowboys in 2025 even if it's Schottenheimer's first season as a head coach and Pickens is the reason why.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!