
The Washington Commanders' fairytale run to last season's NFC Championship game looks exactly that. It's been an unmitigated disaster this time around, giving everyone associated with the franchise a harsh dose of reality, bringing them crashing back down to earth.
A week after defensive coordinator Joe Whitt Jr. was moved from the booth to the sideline, head coach Dan Quinn will now take over his duties. It's a necessary move, but one that's likely too late to save Washington's season.
It's also uncertain how much Whitt's demotion will even fix. Over the course of this season, the cracks in the Commanders' new leadership have been exposed, and it's going to take some time to repair them.
The more time that goes by, the more the Commanders' magical 2024 campaign looks like a perfect storm of momentum and good fortune, without any actual long-term growth being established. They brought in a new coaching staff, a new general manager, and a rookie quarterback. Everything they touched turned to gold.
In retrospect, it all seemed too good to be true.
Jayden Daniels was phenomenal; there's no taking that away. Dan Quinn has legitimate strengths as a head coach, and Adam Peters did what he needed to do after the Commanders' roster was left in no-man's land. But this was not a natural trajectory of a team that won four games the prior year. It didn't erase the fact that there was still plenty of work to do.
The Commanders have now had to reckon with this reality. So far, it's not going well.
Against the Detroit Lions, the culture issues reared their ugly head when Daron Payne was ejected for punching Amon-Ra St. Brown. Javon Kinlaw, who was also involved in the incident, was full of nothing but excuses.
Javon Kinlaw postgame on Payne's ejection, says refs saw St. Brown hit Payne 1st ("it was some bullsh**, 100%") & where #Commanders defense goes from here@JPFinlayNBCS asks about gap from when he signed/where season started to where they are now
— NBC4 Sports (@NBC4Sports) November 10, 2025
"Next question bro"#RaiseHail pic.twitter.com/ocNK6LtiYz
Watching the Commanders be utterly embarrassed by Dan Campbell's Lions, the difference in how the two franchises have rebuilt in recent years could not be starker.
Detroit took a process-based, multi-year approach, and the result is a team with a high floor, built on the culture established during their slow rise. Even after losing both coordinators from last year to head coaching positions, they are comfortably a playoff team.
The Commanders, on the other hand, tried to circumvent that process by chasing instant gratification. It worked temporarily, but success came too fast to instill the type of sustainable structure that comes from years of steady growth.
It's the hard times that mold strong men, and the strong men who build the good times.
It's always easy to celebrate the culture of change when everything is going well. But the actual test of a well-built franchise is how everyone holds up under adversity.
Washington's football franchise isn't ready to pass that test yet, and it's sent them back to where they were supposed to be all along.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!