Penalties, Coaching Mistakes Cost Giants Week 2 Win

The performance from Wilson was something that Giants fans have dreamed of. Through four quarters, he looked like an elite passer who identified every weakness possible in the Dallas defense.

Unfortunately, overtime wasn’t the same story. With both teams seemingly exhausted, Wilson was not as precise, causing a stagnant offense. He ended the Giants’ last overtime possession, forcing a deep ball to Malik Nabers, causing an interception, and putting Dallas in prime field position.

Malik Nabers and Wan’Dale Robinson Have Career Days

Nabers looked like one of the best receivers in football. He had nine catches for 167 yards and two touchdowns. This was arguably the best game of his young career, which is already at a high bar. His two touchdowns showed his otherworldly athleticism and ball-tracking abilities; his second touchdown was caught while the defender was covering his eyes.

With DaRon Bland out for this game, Nabers and Wilson took full advantage of the depleted Dallas backfield. Nabers won what felt like every matchup downfield, and when he wasn’t getting the ball, Wan’Dale took control.

Wan’Dale had the best game of his career, with eight catches for 142 yards and a fourth-quarter touchdown. Before this season, he was nothing more than a short-yardage receiver, never seeing a pass more than ten yards. This game showed what he is fully capable of: burning defenders downfield and settling into the open zones in the intermediate area of the field.

This game was very encouraging for the development of the receiving core, and shows they can be a great group one day soon.

Redzone Offense Continues to Struggle

The Giants have gotten to the red zone seven times this season, scoring a touchdown on just one of those trips. In this game, mental errors left multiple touchdowns off the board — these being a ball hitting Theo Johnson in the head, and the surplus of penalties.

To have a solid offense this season, being poor in the red zone again can’t happen. A more poised offense will need to be on the field come Week 3.

Penalties Destroy Multiple Opportunities

The Giants had a historically bad day of composure, accumulating 14 penalties for 160 yards. These penalties came from both sides of the ball, with numerous calls on the offensive line and everywhere on the defensive side.

The calls started when left tackle James Hudson III was called for four penalties on the opening drive, almost single-handedly gifting Dallas a field goal. After that, the defense was penalized all game, whether it was the line falling for the hard count, late/unnecessary hits, or lack of discipline from the backfield.

If the Giants had even cut their penalties in half this game, they walk away with a convincing win; instead, they lose another divisional matchup, and their playoff chances are already slim.

Edge Rush Group Living Up to Expectations

The edge rush group of Brian Burns, Abdul Carter, and Kayvon Thibodeaux is living up to the hype. They all got pressure on Dak Prescott numerous times and made massive tackles. With Dexter Lawrence getting double-teamed almost every play, this leaves the edge group to take advantage of constant one-on-one opportunities.

The Giants led the league in pressures this week, showing their dominant potential. More snaps with Burns, Carter, and Thibodeaux on the field together must be a priority for the G-Men.

Inconsistent Defensive Back Play

The new, young Giants defensive backfield couldn’t keep up today. Going up against the stellar receiver duo of CeeDee Lamb and George Pickens, the corners struggled. Although there were plenty of good reps from the backfield, especially from Andru Phillips, there was also reason to be concerned.

As the game progressed, the Cowboys had more open targets downfield. The talent is clearly there, though. With more time for them to mesh together and the defensive coordinator Shane Bowen getting a better understanding of their playstyles, they have the chance to improve significantly throughout the season.

Late Game Coaching Spoils Electric Day

The main reason the game went to overtime was coaching. The defensive play calling by Shane Bowen in this game was inexcusable.

After the Giants’ lead-taking touchdown with 25 seconds left in the game, all eyes were on the defense. Twenty-five seconds is a short time for any team, even with three timeouts and an excellent kicker.

Instead of putting pressure on Dak Prescott, something he struggled with throughout the game, Bowen decided to switch to a prevent defense, allowing easy, middle-of-the-field gains and allowing Dallas to walk into field goal range. Because of this late-game coaching blunder, the Giants had to try and win in overtime, something they were clearly not prepared for or had enough energy for.

The overtime collapse falls heavily onto the coaching staff. Brian Daboll and Shane Bowen will be held under a microscope for the rest of the season — more so than they already were.