Miami Dolphins quarterback Tua Tagovailoa returned to practice on Wednesday for the first time since suffering the third concussion of his NFL career in Week 2.
The 26-year-old addressed reporters on Monday and said that despite the trio of head injuries since the 2022 season, he doesn't plan on wearing a Guardian Cap, the protective helmet padding designed to reduce concussions.
Marcel Louis-Jacques — who covers the Dolphins for ESPN — defended Tagovailoa's decision on Wednesday.
The insider wrote on social media that while the 2023 Pro Bowler isn't using a Guardian Cap, he wears the VICIS ZERO2 MATRIX ID QB helmet, which is the "safest helmet for QBs and is graded higher than a regular helmet with a guardian cap over it."
"Don’t clutch pearls here; he could’ve done a better job explaining it Monday but his decision not to wear one is not putting him at any additional disadvantage," Louis-Jacques explained.
The ESPN reporter also responded to fellow journalist Omar Kelly, who covers the Dolphins for the Miami Herald, as well as others who are questioning Tagovailoa's choice.
based on available data and not just claims the NFL has made, the protection a guardian cap provides is marginal, at best https://t.co/h5d3IUFdZ9
— Marcel Louis-Jacques (@Marcel_LJ) October 23, 2024
… But he’s not raw dogging, he’s wearing the safest graded helmet for his position
— Marcel Louis-Jacques (@Marcel_LJ) October 23, 2024
he was concussed because he got too competitive + did something he knows he’s not supposed to do, not because he wasn’t wearing a guardian cap
it’s more useful for guys who bang heads frequently https://t.co/0ufuiaQbUS
I think it’s literally and figuratively putting a hat on a hat
— Marcel Louis-Jacques (@Marcel_LJ) October 23, 2024
i’m sure it is technically safer but statistically speaking, it’s not likely to have prevented a concussion in any of the events in which he hit his head https://t.co/43YS8lVros
It was reported in early October that numerous NFL players were wearing Guardian Caps during the early stages of the regular season, but there were many detractors as well.
An anonymous player poll by The Athletic showed that many athletes chose not to sport the attire due to a host of reasons, including weight, function and even how the padding looked. This, despite NFL officials saying that the Guardian Caps had helped reduce concussions during preseason practices by almost 50%.
Though Tagovailoa has returned to practice, he's not a lock to play in Miami's Week 8 contest against the Arizona Cardinals.
Per Louis-Jacques, the lefty is still in the concussion protocol, though he's been symptom-free since Sept. 13 (one day after his Week 2 concussion on "Thursday Night Football.")
"(Head coach) Mike McDaniel has said multiple times that the progression thru protocol won’t happen until he returns to practice," the media member wrote on X. "A player has to practice in order to progress through the protocol, but they can’t practice until they are eligible to return from IR, hence Tua’s prolonged stay. The final stage before clearance is non-contact football activity — so unless the Dolphins tell us he has cleared, we will not be able to tell simply by observing him at practice (all practice activities are non-contact for quarterbacks.)"
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!