The best laid plans of NFL coaches often go astray, regardless of their experience level or past achievements.
Former New England offensive coordinator Josh McDaniels and his failed attempts as head coach for the Broncos and Raiders is the perfect example. Because there was McDaniels, it's much easier to see how Ben Johnson could have problems as Bears head coach, even after he proved so dynamic as the Lions' play caller.
Despite all of the Bears' offseason moves, the potential for Johnson to step up as head coach and fail will be there until proven otherwise.
In building a case for and against each NFC North team for winning the division in 2025, NFL.com senior news writer Kevin Patra brings up this possibility Johnson could fail transitioning to head coach as a major Bears danger.
"Ben Johnson's job in Chicago is Extreme QB Makeover. The talent is all there, but they've gotta renovate the house."@colincowherd lays out the blueprint for Caleb Williams in Year 2. pic.twitter.com/DtxAJwtj8k
— Herd w/Colin Cowherd (@TheHerd) June 13, 2025
Patra points out all sorts of valid potential reasons why Johnson could struggle, like McDaniels, Adam Gase, Marty Mornhinweg and Cam Cameron did even after they built strong reputations as play callers.
However, Patra fails to grasp onto the one major reason it could happen, even though he gets his hands all over it with his attempt.
The most obvious reason Johnson could fail is because he might not properly develop Caleb Williams due to his own lack of experience at developing young QBs. Patra does ID a possible failure by Williams as the reason Johnson ultimately fails but not because the QB isn't developed properly.
Watching Caleb's season back, he's gonna be just fine. Ben Johnson is going to bring the best out of him. The offense is stacked. Fun to watch. pic.twitter.com/ClYVP6iOF4
— Alex Buck (@AlexandtheNFL) June 17, 2025
Instead, he suggests it's because Williams just doesn't have the ability to be the guy.
Being unable to develop Williams is a real possibility and it has nothing to do with how past staffs failed to develop Mitchell Trubisky and Justin Fields in Chicago. It's a possible problem because the coaches on this staff—offensive coordinator Declan Doyle, passing game coordinator Press Taylor and quarterbacks coach J.T. Barrett—have no more experience developing a young QB than Johnson.
Johnson has had great success calling plays and devising an offense, but does he have the patience to work with a young QB through trial and error on an every day basis? So far so good but it's too early to say.
The lone staff exception to this lack of experience is Taylor, and in Taylor's case it's questionable how much success his work yielded because his young QBs were Carson Wentz and Trevor Lawrence.
Ben Johnson said Aaron Glenn also wanted J.T. Barrett in New York and Barrett had a decision to make.
— Adam Hoge (@AdamHoge) April 1, 2025
Interestingly, had he chosen the Jets, Justin Fields would be his QB. Instead, Barrett is Caleb Williams' QB coach in Chicago.
Offensive coordinator Declan Doyle was a tight ends coach and didn't coach QBs.
Quarterbacks coach J.T. Barrett has no more experience coaching QBs or even playing QB than the last quarterbacks coach, Kerry Joseph. Neither played the position in the NFL, although both had quarterbacking experience in college. In fact, Barrett had less pro experience than Joseph, who was an exceptional CFL QB. Both had been an assistant QB coach two years in the NFL.
Johnson thinks he can draw from work with successful veterans Jared Goff, Ryan Tannehill and Matthew Stafford during the past. In fact, he cited Tannehill as an example of working with an inexperienced QB and then succeeding—but Johnson wasn't the quarterbacks coach, offensive coordinator or any sort of QB coach with Miami back when Tannehill was a young Dolphins QB.
Ryan Tannehill & Mike Vrabel relishing a big win over Dolphins with fans.
— Cameron Wolfe (@CameronWolfe) January 2, 2022
Tannehill gets another division title and likely ends his old ball club Dolphins playoff chances. pic.twitter.com/c5n9jYoYu8
Johnson has described his approach with younger QBs.
"You have to be able to tell them when it's good and when it's not good enough, in front of their peers," Johnson said. "We spend a lot of time together, one-on-one, as well. Some of the best things that I did when I became the coordinator was the quarterback and the play-caller need to see the play exactly the same. You don't develop that trust unless you spend a lot of time together."
Ben Johnson when asked about Caleb Williams’ ability to play on schedule:
— Chicago Bears Network (@bearsnetwork_) June 11, 2025
“I think he’s going to play on time when the receivers present themselves that way. If they’re not there, I think he’s got the ability to make it right for us.” pic.twitter.com/j7aXf1PmuD
All of this might be true, but again, he hasn't actually proven he can do this with a young QB.
Until Williams actually steps forward and combines fewer mistakes consistently with making spectacular plays, the inability to develop a young QB will rate as the No. 1 reason this coaching staff can fail.
Under Ben Johnson, Jared Goff was top 10 in passing yards every single year.
— Jacob Infante (@jacobinfante24) June 12, 2025
That speaks not just to how often he passed, but how efficient his passing game was.
Hoping for similar results with Caleb Williams now that the #Bears have better coaches and OL around him. pic.twitter.com/WbxFU2oOPS
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!