Top QB Matchups on the 2025 Slate: Mahomes vs. Allen in Week 9 MVP Showdown

Few rivalries in the NFL generate as much buzz as Patrick Mahomes vs. Josh Allen. Over the last several seasons, their battles have become must-watch television, consistently delivering high-stakes drama and elite quarterback play. From regular-season thrillers to unforgettable playoff clashes, these two stars have elevated their teams — and the league — with each meeting.

In 2025, the tradition continues. The Kansas City Chiefs will travel to face the Buffalo Bills in a highly anticipated Week 9 matchup. The storylines are already packed: the reigning MVP in Allen going up against Mahomes, a two-time MVP and three-time Super Bowl champion. With both quarterbacks at the peak of their powers, this midseason showdown will have a major impact on how the AFC playoff picture shapes out.

QB Showdown Continues

Patrick Mahomes and Josh Allen have faced each other nine times, with Mahomes holding a narrow 5-4 edge. However, in regular-season matchups, Allen has consistently had the upper hand. He’s won four straight against Mahomes when it hasn’t been the postseason, showcasing his poise and playmaking in those settings.

Buffalo will once again host the Chiefs, and the Bills’ home-field advantage has paid off in the past. Kansas City has struggled in Orchard Park, and Mahomes will look to change that narrative. Despite his overall edge in the series, Allen has repeatedly outdueled him during the regular season.

The real challenge, however, remains in the postseason. Mahomes is 4-0 against Allen in the playoffs, including last season’s AFC Championship win. Still, no regular-season meeting between these teams feels meaningless. Their Week 9 contest will have the feel of a playoff preview — and possibly a future rematch.

Allen’s MVP Rise

Josh Allen enters 2025 as the reigning NFL MVP, and he’s earned it. His 2024 season was a showcase of growth, leadership and elite production. Now, Allen must carry that momentum into a year where expectations are even higher. A win over Mahomes would be another notch on his growing legacy.

Allen’s ability to perform at a high level in the regular season is unquestioned. He’s beaten Mahomes in four straight non-playoff games, and his dynamic play style — mixing powerful throws and mobility — continues to challenge the Chiefs defense. This time, though, he’ll face a revamped Kansas City defense.

Buffalo will likely treat this game as more than just another midseason battle. It’s a statement opportunity. Allen knows that, and so does his team. They’ll be motivated not just to win, but to dominate. The pressure of the MVP spotlight only intensifies this already electric matchup.

Mahomes Looks to Reclaim Crown

After falling one win short of a historic three-peat, Patrick Mahomes is ready to rewrite the script. He may not have taken home the 2024 MVP award, but he once again led the Chiefs deep into the postseason, proving his ability to elevate those around him.

Mahomes thrives under pressure and rarely loses focus, especially when facing other elite quarterbacks. He has repeatedly found ways to exploit the Bills’ defense in the playoffs. If there’s one quarterback who can slow Allen’s momentum, it’s Mahomes. He’ll be aiming to prove that regular-season trends don’t define greatness.

This Week 9 matchup gives Mahomes a prime chance to make an MVP case of his own. A win in Buffalo would not only boost Kansas City’s playoff hopes but also remind the football world that the path to the Super Bowl still runs through No. 15.

Final Thoughts

As NFL rivalries go, few match the intensity and talent of Mahomes vs. Allen. With each quarterback delivering memorable performances in past meetings, fans have come to expect fireworks whenever these teams share the field. Week 9 promises to add another chapter to this growing saga.

Whether it’s about postseason redemption or midseason dominance, this matchup carries weight. Two of the best quarterbacks of their generation will go throw-for-throw in a game that could ultimately shape the AFC’s future. Buckle up — this one will be unforgettable.