Kirby Lee-Imagn Images

Washington Commanders Release Kicker Matt Gay

Originally posted on Total Apex Sports | By Justin Rimpi | Last updated Nov 17, 2025 5:10 PM ET

It’s a tale as old as time in the NFL: you miss, you’re dismissed. For Washington Commanders Kicker Matt Gay, that story became a harsh reality. On Monday, the team announced they were parting ways with Gay, a move that felt as inevitable as a commercial break during a two-minute drill.

This wasn’t just a quiet, end-of-season roster adjustment. This was the direct, brutal fallout from a Sunday that Gay and Commanders fans will be replaying in their nightmares for weeks.

Breaking Down a Poor Sunday In Madrid

Picture this: Madrid, a five-game losing streak hanging over your head like a dark cloud, and a chance to be the hero. With just 15 seconds left in regulation against the Miami Dolphins, Gay lined up for a 56-yard field goal. A successful kick would have not only won the game but also snapped the team’s miserable skid. Instead, the ball sailed wide, the collective groan from the Commanders’ faithful could be heard across the Atlantic, and the game spiraled into overtime.

To add insult to injury, the Dolphins’ Kicker, Riley Patterson, calmly drilled a 29-yarder in OT to seal the deal. It was a gut punch, and Gay felt every bit of it. “100% of the blame for the loss fell on him,” he said. You have to respect the accountability, but in the cutthroat business of professional football, apologies don’t put points on the board.

The Writing On the Wall For Gay

Commanders released veteran K Matt Gay.
— Adam Schefter (@AdamSchefter) November 17, 2025

While Sunday’s meltdown in Madrid was the final straw, the cracks in Gay’s performance had been showing all season. The Commanders signed him to a one-year deal with $4.25 million guaranteed, a decent chunk of change for a kicker. They weren’t just renting a leg; they were hoping for a long-term solution.

But the results just weren’t there. Gay connected on a meager 13 of 19 field goals this season, a success rate of 68.4% that had him ranked 32nd out of 34 qualifying kickers. In a league where kickers are expected to be nearly automatic, that’s simply not going to cut it.

The long ball was his true Achilles’ heel. Gay was a dismal 4-of-9 from beyond 50 yards this year, a troubling trend that carried over from his time with the Indianapolis Colts, where he missed six of nine from that distance last season.

Coach Dan Quinn tried to soften the blow, stating, “The performance, you’ve got to have it. It wasn’t (about) one game.” The Commanders are now 3-7 and back on the kicker carousel. For Gay, a seven-year veteran with a respectable 84% career field goal percentage, it’s a brutal reminder that in the NFL, you’re only as good as your last kick. And unfortunately for him, his last significant one was a miss that cost his team a much-needed win.

This article first appeared on Total Apex Sports and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads: