Who should return kicks for the Giants under the new kickoff rules in 2024?

The Giants’ special teams received a boost last season when the team added special teamer Gunner Olszewski to serve as their return specialist. He didn’t return a single kick, but Olszewski did return 23 punts last season.

On his 23 punt returns, Olszewski totaled 273 yards, averaging 11.9 yards per return, and added one touchdown which came at a decisive moment in a close game against the Los Angeles Rams in Week 17. He was named NFC Special Teams Player of the Week for his performance in that game.

The Giants signed Olszewski to an extension this offseason, indicating they still view him as their primary return specialist. However, considering he only returned punts last season, and also considering the kickoff format has changed, Olszewski could be the team’s punt returner while a different skill position player takes over on kickoffs.

Could another skill position player take over on kick returns?

One player who could compete for the Giants’ starting kick return job is rookie running back Tyrone Tracy Jr. The former wide receiver converted running back is a tackle-breaking machine, forcing 46 missed tackles in 2023 on just 146 carries.

Tracy’s ability to break tackles and create explosive plays could translate well to the new kickoff format. Under the new rules, more kicks are expected to be returned, rather than conceded into touchbacks. Some teams may decide to put more skilled position players back on kick returns in an effort to create explosive plays and scoring opportunities on special teams.

Tracy has breakaway ability as a rusher which could make him a dangerous return specialist. He will likely compete for the role throughout the summer, alongside other skill position players, like wide receiver Isaiah McKenzie and fellow running back Eric Gray.