
The time has come for the Miami Dolphins to blow it all up and start all over again. Something that may mean more pain for fans in the immediate future is needed for the once-proud franchise to ever return to relevancy.
Miami not only sits at 1-6, arguably one of the worst teams in the entire NFL, but it has become such a soap opera that it might actually be more embarrassing than the only AFC East team it is above in the standings — the 0-7 New York Jets.
Former Dolphins offensive lineman Richie Incognito waxed poetic on what's wrong with the entire Dolphins team. And while some may dismiss Incognito as the messenger due to his controversial background, everything he said is right on the money.
"I hate this. I hate the whole situation they have brewing down there. This is a dumpster fire and you have [Mike] McDaniel and Tua [Tagovailoa] throwing bags of gasoline into the dumpster fire," Incognito said on "The Arena: Gridiron" show.
"We look at this guy on TV (McDaniel) and I do not see a leader of men. When I'm going out there on Sunday and I want to rip someone's head off, I'm not getting fired up by this guy's pregame speech."
Incognito then switched gears and went in on the Dolphins franchise quarterback as well.
"I hate this. This is a dumpster fire. Mike McDaniel and Tua are throwing bags of gasoline into the dumpster fire."@68INCOGNITO and The Crew are fed up with the drama in Miami. pic.twitter.com/98Zj7UKent
— The Arena: Gridiron (@ArenaGridiron) October 21, 2025
"Tua last week was talking about guys being late and he's talking about leadership. Well, leadership starts and ends with Tua because you're the franchise quarterback."
What Incognito is pointing out shows how fractured and dramatic the locker room is, in addition to being a flawed roster.
The Dolphins are coming off one of their worst performances of the season, losing 31-6 to the Browns, a fellow last-place team. And even though Tyreek Hill's season-ending injury can be used as a minor excuse for their recent weeks, the Dolphins offense has been among the worst in the NFL all year. Miami has actually failed to reach 30 points in any game so far this season.
McDaniel, once billed as an offensive innovator, seems to have no answers as Tagovailoa continues to regress each week (as evident by his 11 touchdowns to 10 interceptions), causing a lack of confidence in the most important position beyond anything he says to the media.
Few expected anything from the defense, but it's still worth noting the unit has given up the seventh-most yards per game in the league and has allowed four of seven opponents, to date, to score at least 30 points against it. Every team the Dolphins have faced has put up at least 20.
In an NFL coaching landscape that sees teams cut bait after just one season, McDaniel is in his fourth year in Miami. And after back-to-back playoff appearances, McDaniel is now headed for his second consecutive losing season, likely one that will finish far worse than 2024's 8-9 mark.
If there don't appear to be any signs of improvement on the field and there are questions about leadership off it, the next logical step is for ownership to take matters into its own hands and make a change. Put McDaniel out of his misery and move on from Tagovailoa any way you can. Make those moves and then worry about building the rest of the team all over again.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!