He’s not the flashiest name on draft boards, but that’s exactly what makes him intriguing. Former USC standout Michael Pittman Jr. has carved out a reputation in the NFL as a reliable, high-volume possession receiver for the Indianapolis Colts.
Now, entering 2025 with a new quarterback in Daniel Jones, Pittman’s fantasy football stock quickly and quietly rising.
For fantasy managers hunting value in the middle to late rounds, Pittman offers the perfect blend of floor, opportunity, and system fit.
Across the past three seasons, Pittman has caught 296 passes for 3,159 yards—numbers that speak to both his dependability and his consistency as a target hog.
Even in 2024, a season defined by instability at quarterback and a run-heavy Colts offense, Pittman still produced 69 receptions, 808 yards, and three touchdowns.
That stat line won’t turn heads on its own, but it does highlight Pittman’s ability to maintain WR3/Flex-level production despite less-than-ideal circumstances.
Jones doesn’t sling deep balls down the sideline like Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen or stretch the field like Kansas City Chiefs star Patrick Mahomes. What he does well is hit short-to-intermediate throws with accuracy.
In 2024, Jones posted a 63.3 percent completion rate, excelling in true completion percentage (71.1 percent) and intermediate accuracy.
That is precisely where Pittman thrives. His average depth of target last year (10.9 yards) lines up perfectly with Jones’s comfort zone: throws between the numbers, quick timing routes, and security-blanket targets.
Pittman has the frame (6-foot-4, 223 pounds) and catch radius to give Jones an outlet when the pocket collapses, which should increase both his target volume and his efficiency.
Even more encouraging, Pittman averaged just 10 fantasy points per game with rookie Anthony Richardson last year, but when paired with more accurate quarterbacks, his average spiked closer to 15.8 fantasy points per game. That’s a significant bump that shows how much quarterback fit matters to his value.
Pittman isn’t being drafted as a top-25 wideout. His current ADP makes him a mid-to-late round option, often slipping into WR3 or Flex territory.
That’s where the value lies. If Jones locks onto him as the Colts’ primary chain-mover, Pittman has the potential to outperform his draft slot and offer steady weekly production.
He won’t win you a week with a 40-point explosion, but he can keep your roster afloat with steady 12–16 point outings.
For managers who load up on running backs early or target higher-ceiling wide receivers, Pittman is the kind of stabilizing option that rounds out a championship lineup.
Michael Pittman Jr. may not generate highlight-reel buzz, but fantasy football is won on value and consistency as much as upside.
His profile as Daniel Jones’s go-to intermediate target sets him up for a bounce-back year that could surprise a lot of managers.
Former USC star. Proven possession receiver. A quarterback who thrives in his range. That’s the kind of formula that screams sleeper.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!