The Columbus Blue Jackets dropped their final home preseason game Tuesday night, falling 4-3 to the Washington Capitals at Nationwide Arena. With a full NHL roster on the ice (minus Kirill Marchenko), the Blue Jackets now sit at 2-4-0 in exhibition play. The next time they return to Nationwide Arena will be for the regular season home opener on Monday, Oct. 13, against the New Jersey Devils.
Connor McMichael and Tom Wilson both tallied a goal and an assist for the Capitals, while Logan Thompson stopped 36 of 39 shots to earn the win.
Captain Boone Jenner scored twice on the power play in the second period, and Mathieu Olivier added a third-period goal to pull Columbus within one. Zach Werenski picked up two assists, and Jet Greaves made 19 saves on 23 shots in a performance that had some tough moments but was solid overall.
Here are three takeaways from the loss.
Even though the Blue Jackets outshot the Capitals 39-23, they couldn’t overcome a couple of fluky goals and some costly turnovers. One of the flukier ones came in the first period on the penalty kill. Andrew Cristall got the puck after Columbus failed to clear, backhanded it toward the net, and it went off Dante Fabbro’s skate before sliding through Greaves’s five-hole. Just a weird and unlucky bounce all around.
The “boneheaded” mistake of the night came later in the middle frame. Fabbro brought the puck out from behind the net and skated it right into a forechecker, Tom Wilson, while another forechecker came around the other side. Wilson poked the puck off Fabbro’s stick, and it squeaked through Greaves again – another five-hole goal, and one that was completely avoidable.
that miro-willy teamwork makes the dream work pic.twitter.com/YfA2c5JYot
— Washington Capitals (@Capitals) October 1, 2025
Head coach Dean Evason spoke on the “sloppy” play throughout most of the game, harping more on the lack of sharpness rather than the turnovers.
“We didn’t play bad hockey, but we played pretty sloppy, that’s how we were talking about it in there. Our execution tonight wasn’t there. I don’t think it was about turning it over, obviously, we did on a couple goals, but for the most part, it was just a little sloppy.”
Evason did mention some positives, especially on special teams. The penalty kill went 0-for-1 but looked organized, and the power play showed signs of life. With eight days until the season opener, there is time to clean things up.
“We’ve got a couple of days to correct some stuff. We’ve got some good teaching material; a lack of straightforwardness. We need to get to the net, get pucks on net. They did a good job blocking and keeping us away. We had attempts, but not enough quality. We need to simplify, go straight forward, and improve our execution.”
Greaves didn’t have his best night, but he wasn’t the reason for the loss either. Three of the goals against came off deflections and screens, and the team in front of him didn’t do him many favors.
Werenski backed his goalie post-game and made it clear the group has confidence in him.
“Jet played great. I mean, a couple of goals, there’s nothing he can do on them. All sticks and legs and screens. So, I’m definitely confident in our group right now.”
Evason also suggested they were more about team breakdowns and a lack of puck luck than goaltending.
“We basically scored three goals in our net, right? It was just our execution tonight wasn’t there. It was just a little bit sloppy, and we need to clean it up.”
The power play was one of the bright spots on Tuesday night. Jenner scored twice on the man advantage, both times from his usual spot in front of the net. Columbus runs a 1-3-1 setup, and Jenner is the net-front guy, causing havoc most times. Both goals came from traffic, deflections, and rebounds, including one that went in off his skate on a double screen.
CAP STRIKES TWICE!
— Columbus Blue Jackets (@BlueJacketsNHL) October 1, 2025
CBJ x @FanaticsBook pic.twitter.com/qpVbZOIC7J
That is the kind of gritty, simple style that worked for them last season when the power play was rolling.
Post-game, Jenner talked about the unit starting to click this preseason.
“We want to be a difference maker. When you get opportunities, you want to give your team some juice and life. With the personnel we have, I think we can be a really good power play. We’ve been working on it, talking about it. I think we read off each other quite well. A lot of guys were on that unit last year, so we can build off it. We want to be dangerous and score every time we go out.”
Faceoffs were another area where the Blue Jackets looked sharp. They won 5 of 7 draws (71%) on the power play, with Sean Monahan going 4-for-5 (80%) as the top unit’s centerman. Winning possession off the draw is huge, especially on the man advantage, and they did a good job of that.
Werenski, who quarterbacks the top unit from the blue line, mentioned how important those early touches are.
“I thought we were sustaining some offensive zone time, had chances, scored goals. Off the faceoff, which is what we wanted, attack right away. Our entries were good. It’s a huge thing for our group, and hopefully we can keep it rolling into the season.”
The Blue Jackets will have a few days of practice before wrapping up their preseason Saturday in Washington, D.C.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!