Mike Matheson is considered to be the current punching boy of the Montreal Canadiens fan base after having a season where his role switched over, thanks to the emergence of Lane Hutson from power-play QB to a role where he was responsible for shutting down the top players on opposing teams. However, he gave the puck away too often by trying to carry the puck up ice on his own. Nonetheless, his role on the team can still be very important to the team for the upcoming season.
One of the biggest issues in recent years was that Mike Matheson was playing too many minutes each night, but his offensive game was still a big factor before the 2024-25 season. Now that this upcoming season, he’s likely to see very limited, if any, power-play minutes, with the acquisition of Noah Dobson and Lane Hutson continuing to take the league by a storm, Matheson will need to shift his attention to the defensive side of the game.
Despite the responsibility of the power-play being removed from him, it seems the younger defenseman on the team still looks up to Matheson. This is the main reason the Habs should keep him for the final year of his deal. It could be a different story if Kent Hughes gets an amazing offer for Matheson, but if the Habs can’t get at least a 1st rounder and a prospect for him, then it may be best to keep him. He can still serve as a leader to a very young defensive core that needs a vet to help some of them transition into their full potential.
With Kaiden Guhle and Lane Hutson both being left-handed defensemen who are growing their games and are ready for big minutes, Matheson may be playing only 18-20 minutes per game for the first time since being traded to Montreal. Also, with the acquisition of Dobson, the Habs won’t rely on Matheson as much for offense. Matheson has proven that he can be a good defensive presence when he focuses on that part of his game, as seen from his penalty kill work. The coaches may need to work with him so he can avoid making those bad turnovers, but it can be worked around if his role is to play a defensive game.
If at training camp, the coaches discuss a role change for Matheson, he seems like the type of player who would be willing to embrace whatever role the Habs give him. The role should consist of Matheson skating the puck out of the zone and looking to make an outlet pass rather than trying to carry it up himself or depending on his defensive partner, letting them carry the puck up instead. Knowing the way the Habs like to roll out their pairings, it is very likely that Matheson will play with either Dobson or Hutson to start the year. With those guys, there is no reason for Matheson to try playing hero puck. The fact that he played with Dobson at this year’s World Championships makes me believe the Habs brass may put the two defensemen together to start training camp.
There is a chance he could be playing on a 3rd pairing with either Jayden Struble, Alex Carrier or Arber Xhekaj, which would probably be the best way to spread out the puck-moving defensemen, but the Habs seem to really like Matheson in the top 4.
In the case of Matheson going down to the 3rd pairing, I’d make it balanced so that all six defenseman get close to the same ice time. My pairings would be the following: Guhle-Dobson Hutson-Struble Matheson-Carrier
With these pairings, you can run all three at any time of the game, and not worry. Sure, the Hutson-Struble pairing would be the one most sheltered by starting in the offensive zone, but both guys proved to play their best 5-on-5 hockey together last season. As a result, it would likely push Matheson down to play with Carrier when everyone is healthy. Those two seem to have had chemistry at times during this past season. Therefore, it would all work in the long run.
Who do you think Matheson should be paired with to start this upcoming season?
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!