During a routine morning skate Thursday morning at Scotiabank Arena, Toronto Maple Leafs head coach Craig Berube bellows a simple directive for his five star players assembled on the team’s top power play unit.
“Let’s get a shot right away!” Berube yells, with Morgan Rielly, Auston Matthews, William Nylander, Matthew Knies and John Tavares standing attentively. Toronto is operating a four-forward power play with Rielly orchestrating from the top, after running a five-forward power play during the second half of last year. The change may have served as an inflection point: Toronto connected at a 24.8 percent clip last season, tied for the 8th-best mark in the NHL. After switching to the five-forward format during a January 14 contest against the Dallas Stars, the Maple Leafs scored at a 30.4 percent clip for the rest of the year, the second-best mark in the league, trailing only the Vegas Golden Knights. So why has there been a switch?
There’s a certain 102-point winger who is persona non grata, at least through the latter half of training camp, and it will be a collective effort to replicate the offence and playmaking that Mitch Marner possesses. Dakota Joshua, Nicolas Roy and Matias Maccelli will add real depth and secondary scoring to the Maple Leafs’ lineup, but of the new additions, only Maccelli is a realistic fit with the man advantage. And with this in mind, Berube wants his defencemen to orchestrate from the top and get a shot quickly in the power play. Toronto’s defencemen executed Berube’s north-south instruction well last year but rarely generated meaningful offence. And now Morgan Rielly will operate from the top on the first power play unit, while Oliver Ekman-Larsson oversees the second group. Shooters shoot, and Berube’s instruction has been clear, simple and effective throughout training camp.
“Nothing different than he’s always been told,” Berube said of his instruction to Rielly, following Thursday’s morning skate. “He’s a good power play guy. He’s been a good power play guy here for a long time. We went to five forwards last year. It clicked. It worked. So we stuck with it. But now it’s changed. So he’s up top. He needs to establish a shot, I think, more than anything. Getting a shot from the top, earning a power play, does a lot of good. He’s got to make sure that he’s a threat up top to shoot the puck when he has opportunities. He can’t always want to distribute it all the time. We do need to move it and distribute it to the flanks at times, but he’s got to be a shooter.”
Theory turned into practice quickly. Rielly got a shot off immediately after John Tavares won the puck off the draw during Thursday’s preseason game against the Detroit Red Wings. John Tavares deflected Rielly’s shot, Matthew Knies fished out a loose puck in the slot, fired it over to Auston Matthews, who made no mistake. It’s simple offence, and it allows Berube’s power forwards to jam away at loose pucks in high-danger areas, core tenets of his philosophy — Tavares and Knies will rotate between the bumper and net-front spots all season, Matthews and Nylander will be on the flanks and Rielly will operate almost as a deep-lying midfielder, governing the flow of the offence.
“I think that’s what we want to establish early on, is finding a shot,” Matthews said after Thursday’s game. “We got two big guys that are in the middle and in front of the net and let you tip pucks and create rebounds. I think that’s been a point of emphasis. Then trying to break down the structure from there once we recover the pock or whatever happens from there. Using our instincts, but especially early on, trying to get pucks through and try to create some havoc at the net.”
The Captain delivers!
️: Sportsnet | NHL pic.twitter.com/d6Lb9GORTu
— TheLeafsNation (@TLNdc) October 2, 2025
Rielly rejected the hypothesis that it’s a new point of emphasis, but getting a shot off quickly is what Berube is instructing from his power play unit through October. He’s the longest-tenured Maple Leafs player and has played ample time on the power play throughout his career, but his role may be magnified in a way that it hasn’t been in the past.
“There’s always an emphasis on that, I think. But it’s always fun playing with those highly skilled players, and so you just try to do your part,” Rielly said post-game Thursday.
And perhaps the shift in format may be academic to the casual observer, but it’s clear that Rielly’s vision and decision-making are lauded by his teammates.
“I think the way Mo moves up top there and makes plays, he’s a really good player that can see the ice, so it’s good,” Maple Leafs forward Scott Laughton said to The Leafs Nation on Thursday. “I don’t see much of a difference. Obviously, we had a really good power play last year, and Mitchy was on top, but slide in a couple of guys there, and it’s a really good power play overall, so I don’t see much of a difference.”
Ekman-Larsson expanded on the role of the defenceman on the power play, along with the freedom and improvisational qualities that the job can require.
“I think, obviously, you have your guidelines,” Ekman-Larsson told The Leafs Nation at Thursday’s morning skate. “If you can say that, it’s you know what you’re doing on the breakout. You know the set plays in the zone. But most of the times it’s just a read. And that’s what good players do. And that’s why we have the players that we have on the power play. They make good reads and it happens quick, right? So I think it’s just a read and obviously sticking to simplifying it a little bit. Sometimes when you struggle, you cannot look at that next play instead of maybe shooting it and stuff like that.”
Resetting at the top was a core concept for the Maple Leafs’ power play last season, and through the preseason, Rielly has been in excellent form, showing an increased willingness to shoot, to go along with a renewed commitment in rush defence scenarios. Here’s an example from the September 23 game against the Ottawa Senators. Matthews surveys the zone, doesn’t have a shooting lane and gets the puck back to Rielly, who one-times it directly at the net, with Tavares set up in the bumper role and Knies getting to the net-front. The puck ricochets back to Matthews, who once again surveys the ice, resets to Rielly, who then goes back to Matthews, who is now open on the flank. Ottawa quickly closes on Matthews’ shooting lanes, he resets to Rielly again, who once again launches it towards the net. It didn’t lead to a goal, but the process is working, as Toronto is looking to generate more offence from the blue line this season.
Rielly's making more of an effort to shoot now that he got his spot back on the top unit pic.twitter.com/dwIfLCUW3k
— Omar (@TicTacTOmar) September 24, 2025
Without an all-world playmaker in the lineup, it will be a collective effort but this is still a star-studded Maple Leafs team up front. Berube knows this inherently and is letting his best players operate to their strengths, with a renewed commitment to simple, direct hockey.
Although the Maple Leafs lost Thursday’s preseason tuneup, Berube is content with Rielly’s orchestration of the power play. A renewed commitment to resetting at the top and getting shots before the base defence gets set could go a long way for a Maple Leafs team that will need to punish teams routinely on the man advantage, in order to secure their status as a Stanley Cup contender.
“Well, what he did right away, was shot it, right? Created the shot, created the stress and the chaos. I think just being direct like that. We want to establish a quick shot early in the power play and we’re doing that. That’s a big, key thing.”
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!