Toronto Maple Leafs News

Home

Quizzes

Newsletter

Auston Matthews, Toronto Maple Leafs (Jess Starr/The Hockey Writers)

Maple Leafs News & Rumours: Matthews, McCabe, Carlo & Nylander

Originally posted on The Hockey Writers | By The Old Prof | Last updated Jan 6, 2026 1:15 PM ET

The Toronto Maple Leafs return to Scotiabank Arena tonight to face the Florida Panthers in a game that feels heavier than a typical January meeting. Toronto is riding a six-game point streak and welcoming home a captain who rewrote franchise history on Saturday.

On the other hand, Florida arrives battered, short-staffed, and still very dangerous. It’s a classic measuring-stick night and the kind of game that the Maple Leafs have often lost in the past. This one, they can’t afford to coast into. But, on the plus side, they’re riding a hot captain, and their offence is keeping them in games. On the negative, the Panthers seem to thrive on discomfort.

Item One: Auston Matthews Is Playing Like He Remembers Who He Was

Auston Matthews doesn’t look like a player chasing records; he seems like one who’s already absorbed them. With six goals and ten points over his last four games, Matthews has surged past Mats Sundin to become the Maple Leafs’ all-time goals leader, and he’s done it without turning it into a sideshow. The goals are coming in bunches, his shot is suddenly lethal again, and the puck seems glued to his stick in all three zones.

What stands out most is how Matthews describes his own game. He’s talking about legs, speed, and possession—about having the puck more, not forcing it. He’s speaking from comfort rather than pressure. For a Maple Leafs team that has too often felt tight when expectations rise, Matthews’ calm dominance is helping to set a confident tone.

Item Two: Maple Leafs Points Are Piling Up, but Leads Are Still Slipping Away

Toronto has picked up points in six straight games, and that matters in the standings. But the coaching staff hasn’t been shy about what still bothers them. Against the New York Islanders on Saturday, the Maple Leafs twice let third-period leads slip away, sitting back instead of pushing for separation. The result was another overtime finish and another missed chance to put a game away.

Head coach Craig Berube’s comments afterward were telling. For him, his team’s inability to put teams away isn’t about systems as much as it is about mindset. When Toronto gets conservative, they stop owning the puck. And when they stop owning the puck, chaos creeps in. Against a Panthers team that thrives on opportunistic moments, staying aggressive with a lead isn’t optional. It’s survival.

Item Three: The Maple Leafs’ Blue Line Is in Flux Again

The Maple Leafs’ defence remains a work in progress, with Jake McCabe likely out for up to a week after leaving Saturday’s game with a lower-body injury. That’s another disruption for a group that’s already been juggling roles and minutes. The good news is that Brandon Carlo will return tonight after recovering from foot surgery, which will help stabilize the back end.

Brandon Carlo, Toronto Maple Leafs (Dan Hamilton-Imagn Images)

Toronto also recalled Marshall Rifai from their American Hockey League affiliate, the Toronto Marlies, a reminder that depth is being tested again. How quickly the defence settles—and how confidently they move the puck under pressure—will go a long way toward determining whether the Maple Leafs can finally protect a lead against a heavy forechecking team like Florida.

Item Four: William Nylander Moves to Injured Reserve

The Maple Leafs placed William Nylander on injured reserve on Monday, a move that’s more about paperwork than panic. The designation is retroactive to December 27, meaning Nylander can return as soon as he’s cleared, but it also confirms the team doesn’t see this as a day-to-day situation just yet.

Nylander has already missed four games with a lower-body injury, and his absence is noticeable. With 14 goals and a team-leading 41 points in 33 games, he’s been one of Toronto’s most consistent drivers of offence. He’s been especially productive at five-on-five. When the Maple Leafs need a line to tilt the ice, Nylander is usually at the centre of it.

William Nylander of the Toronto Maple Leafs celebrates his goal against the Florida Panthers during the first period of Game One of the Second Round of the 2025 Stanley Cup Playoffs (Photo by Mark Blinch/NHLI via Getty Images)

The Maple Leafs have been doing okay without their team-leading scorer and must learn to be patient, but they’re also eager to get Nylander back sooner rather than later. They need him as the schedule tightens and the margin for error continues to shrink.

What’s Next for the Maple Leafs?

Tonight is about more than Matthews’ homecoming after setting the all-time goal-scoring record. It’s about whether the Maple Leafs can stay assertive when the game tightens, protect a lead when it matters, and match the emotional grind a team like the Panthers brings every night.

The points are there for the taking, but the test is real.