Welcome to NHL Rumours! We are just over 24 hours away from the start of the 2025 Stanley Cup Playoffs. Yet, our rumour today is about a team who got close to the Final, but fell just short in the Western Conference Final . Our rumour looks at the Dallas Stars, who might be dealing with tensions between head coach Pete DeBoer and the players.
Rumour: David Pagnotta, an analysis with the NHL Network, has heard from sources that there are tensions in the Dallas Stars locker room. Players are unhappy with how head coach Peter DeBoer handled situations during the Western Conference Final, as well as his remarks following their elimination and during the exit interview.
Noise out of Dallas re: Pete DeBoer. Per multiple sources, players are not pleased with how he handled several situations during the WCF, along with post Gm5 & exit media remarks. Told players voiced concerns during internal exit interviews. DeBoer has 1yr left on his contract.
— David Pagnotta (@TheFourthPeriod) June 2, 2025
Analysis: This has to be a frustrating time to be a Stars fan, player, coach, or member of the front office. The Stars have been eliminated in the Western Conference Finals each of the last three seasons. The Stars roster is consistently talented, yet, they are still seeking success in the third round.
It is understandable that these frustrations are beginning to show. Furthermore, this latest elimination was by far the worst of the three. After rallying to win Game 1, the Stars lost four in a row. Mikko Rantanen, the big trade acquisition from this season who saved the Dallas season in round one, went scoreless in the series. Goaltender Jake Oettinger struggled in the series, giving up at least three goals in each game he completed.
This is where the tensions have arisen.
In Game 5, the Stars found themselves down 2-0 a little over seven minutes into the game. After Oettinger gave up two goals on two shots, DeBoer replaced him with Casey DeSmith. Oettinger was surprised to be pulled, but admitted he was struggling.
“I wasn’t expecting that to happen. It was surprising,” he said. “But the reality is, if I make one or two of those saves, I’d still (be playing) in the game.”
Following the Game 5 loss, DeBoer was asked about his decision to pull Oettinger. His response is what has caused tensions to arise.
“Anytime you pull a goalie, the reasoning is always to try and spark your group,” DeBoer said. “Obviously, we were in a 2-0 hole right away, and I didn’t take that lightly and I didn’t blame it all on Jake, but the reality is… he’s lost six of seven games to Edmonton.“
Obviously, it is easy to see how this could ruffle feathers in the Dallas locker room. DeBoer’s comment placed the blame on Oettinger. Many would agree that DeBoer should have stopped his comment after talking about sparking the group.
This is not the first time DeBoer has caused controversy in the playoffs with his goaltending decisions. During the 2020 Stanley Cup Playoffs, when DeBoer coached the Vegas Golden Knights, DeBoer benched Marc-Andre Fleury for Robin Lehner. The Golden Knights lost in the Western Conference Final to, coincidentally, the Stars.
There is some clearly some reconciliation that needs to occur between DeBoer and the Stars team. It has been less than a week since the team was eliminated, so there may be no reason to jump to conclusions yet. However, DeBoer just have one year left on his contract. Following three-straight losses in the Western Conference Final, the Stars front office might wonder if DeBoer can get the Stars over the hump.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!
Edmonton Oilers superstar captain Connor McDavid, who can become a UFA next July 1, reportedly has a new contract extension timeline per a new report from the 2 Mutts Podcast. The Edmonton Oilers still have a major matter of important business to take care of, as superstar captain Connor McDavid can become perhaps the highest-profile UFA in NHL history next July 1. Team Canada's Orientation Camp Could Be the Key to McDavid's Next Oilers Deal McDavid, who didn't exactly sound like he was rushing into a new contract extension with the Oilers following their 2nd straight loss in the SCF to the Florida Panthers earlier this year, will play for Canada in the 2026 Winter Milan Olympics. Per the 2 Mutts Podcast, the Oilers could potentially get McDavid to sign a shorter-term extension during Canada's Orientation Camp in late August in Calgary. We are hearing that the contract extension for Connor McDavid will most likely happen after the Team Canada Orientation Camp which is August 26th to the 28th in Calgary. The plan is to announce the contract extension before the Captain Skates begin Training Camp starts. We believe it could be a 2 year deal or a 4 year deal as the @EdmontonOilers already know McDavid won't be signing an 8 year extension this time around. The conversation on AAV has gone from $16M to around $17.5M from what we've been told. Right now, McDavid makes an AAV (average annual value) of $12 million on the deal he signed in 2017. The Oilers have already re-signed both Leon Draisaitl and Evan Bouchard While they try and work out an extension for McDavid, the Oilers have already re-signed both Leon Draisaitl and Evan Bouchard to massive extensions. Draisaitl makes an AAV of $14 million, while Bouchard recently agreed to a new deal with an AAV of $10.5 million. With McDavid's alleged impending extension, the Oilers could have over $40 million dedicated to just 3 players on the roster.
A veteran Green Bay Packers wide receiver didn’t leave a good impression on head coach Matt LaFleur’s coaching staff on Saturday when he took on his old team in front of 71,501 fans at Lambeau Field on Saturday night. Mecole Hardman, who has had flashes of being a strong contributor to the Packers during training camp, struggled in the Packers’ 30-10 loss to the New York Jets. The 2019 second-round pick by the Kansas City Chiefs dropped his only target of the night and made a poor decision as a punt returner on special teams before muffing a punt on his second punt return opportunity. The Green Bay Packers coaching staff has a decision to make Matt Schneidman of The Athletic suggested that Hardman’s performance will prompt the Packers’ coaching staff to reevaluate the receiver depth chart. “Hardman, too, seemed penciled into the 53-man roster before Saturday night,” Schneidman wrote. “For a player who probably wasn’t slated to contribute much as a wide receiver come the regular season but still provided value because of his return experience, the preseason opener was a disaster. “Hardman fielded a punt on the fly at his 5-yard line (that’s a no-no) with a Jet and two Packers nearby and was tackled immediately for no gain by the Jets’ Qwan’tez Stiggers after he beat Packers rookie seventh-round cornerback Micah Robinson.” “I made two bad decisions, so that’s on me,” Hardman told reporters after the game. Hardman wasn’t the only Packers receiver to have issues against the Jets, as an issue from 2024, dropped passes, continued to plague the offense in their first preseason game of 2025. It’s an issue Hardman and the team will want to show improvement on when they play the Indianapolis Colts on Saturday.
Washington Commanders HC Dan Quinn spoke with the media before practice today and continued to express his displeasure with the team's results in their blowout loss on Friday night. He spoke about the depth he likes on the team, but also hinted at some positions that could use some help. Quinn also said that the team would be working out a handful of players following practice today, and that they are always willing to improve the team where it's possible. Well, the Commanders signed a player today following the workouts that could hint at what Quinn was talking about, and more. Commanders sign former third-round pick The Commanders are signing a former third-round pick in LB Duke Riley, who was actually drafted by the Atlanta Falcons when Dan Quinn was the head coach there. This signing comes after the Commanders worked out 14 players after practice today, which contained seven linebackers and no wide receivers. After the performance we saw in the first preseason game on defense and special teams, these workouts shouldn't be surprising though. Riley was a starting linebacker in Atlanta when he was drafted in 2017, and eventually landed in Miami in 2021, where he has been a rotational linebacker and special-teams defender. That tells me a lot about what they saw on film after watching the first preseason game. Could the writing be on the wall? This immediately raises two flags for me: who would he replace on special teams, and what does this mean for the health of another linebacker? When you go back and watch the film, Dominique Hampton did not look good at all at his new linebacker position, and I don't have him making the active roster. The team also drafted Kain Medrano, who is listed as a linebacker on the depth chart by the team. Other than that, the Commanders have no true depth at linebacker. You have a special-teams ace who can't play linebacker, and a linebacker who can't play special teams. That's not a good combo for roster cuts. Veteran Nick Bellore has been an outstanding special-teams player, but could his lack of ability at linebacker cost the 36-year-old? Hopeful second-round linebacker Jordan Magee has so much potential, but he's already dealing with an undisclosed injury after playing only 16 snaps in his rookie season due to injuries. Signing Riley, who can rotate at linebacker and be a key special-teams piece, means that the team either doesn't like what they saw on film with special teams, or they aren't sure if Magee can stay healthy. Either way, this signing is filling in two major needs right now.
The Boston Red Sox are trying to do something they haven’t done in a few years: return to the playoffs. Boston has the pieces necessary to do so. The rotation is cooking and led by a bona fide Cy Young Award contender in Garrett Crochet. The Red Sox’s offense is clicking and has some superstar pieces, like Alex Bregman. The bullpen is arguably the best in baseball. And it doesn’t hurt that the defense has shown some signs of improvement. One of the biggest reasons for this is Trevor Story’s play this season. He has been great overall. Story’s first green seasons in Boston were marred by injuries so the fact that he’s been able to stay healthy this season is a testament to his work throughout the offseason, plus some good luck. Story is a phenomenal defender and has been one of the team’s top right-handed bats. He entered play on Sunday slashing .256/.302/.423 with 18 homers, 73 RBIs, and 19 stolen bases in 114 games played. If the Red Sox can make it back to the playoffs, they are going to need him at his best. Red Sox's Trevor Story gets stamp of approval from manager Alex Cora Red Sox manager Alex Cora was asked about Story and shared that there won’t be times down the stretch that he’s given days off and that the team is going to rely on him. "Manager Alex Cora doesn’t see himself giving Red Sox shortstop Trevor Story any more days off this year," MassLive.com's Christopher Smith shared. "'There’s no need,' Cora said. 'Physically he’s unique. He looks, stronger, he’s moving well, swinging the bat well. So this is something he wanted to do and he forced us to do.'" The Red Sox are going to need him at his best down the stretch. Boston's depth has been tested at times throughout the season, but Story has been a right-handed slugger the club has needed. Last year, this wasn't the case for Boston. The lineup wasn't balanced and the club was lacking right-handed pop. Story has provided that and then some this year. It also doesn't hurt having Alex Bregman in the lineup as well. Overall, Story is a key that can unlock this team and fans will see plenty of him down the stretch as Boston tries to get back to the playoffs.