x
The Canucks’ Pettersson Dilemma: If He’s Back… Now What?
IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Vancouver Canucks fans are basically in a wait-and-see mood with Elias Pettersson, and you can feel why. A lot of people haven’t seen “that guy” in a while. The player they came to appreciate is gone. No more watching the sharp thinking, the clean look on the ice, the ability to just dazzle like he did when he first came up. Lately it’s felt off.

It’s not really like he’s playing bad hockey. There’s more like something’s been holding him back. It’s like he’s not fully right, or at least not moving the way you expect from him. The big question is simple but brutal. So, what happens if he suddenly turns it on and has a monster season

What Happens If Pettersson Trends Upward?

Because the dilemma goes both ways. If Pettersson bounces back hard, the Canucks might finally get the player they paid for and built around. But then it creates a whole new problem. Do they keep him and commit, or do they start wondering if they should trade him while his value is sky-high?

If he looks like the real No. 1 centre again, other teams will notice fast. And when other teams get interested, suddenly you don’t just have “good news,” you have leverage. And is leverage something this Canucks team wants? It usually comes with temptation. Do you “enjoy the win” and move forward, or do you worry it’s only a one-off and try to cash in?

What Happens If Pettersson Slides Lower?

On the flip side, if he has another rough season, Vancouver probably stops waiting and starts planning for the future, even if the return isn’t what they’d hoped for. Nobody wants to live in the in-between forever.

Either way, it’s tense: a monster season could make decisions harder. And a bad year could force the Canucks’ hand, but they might not have much to show for it. The Canucks’ offseason stress might not be about what Pettersson does this year—it might be about what it means after he does it.

The interesting part is that either outcome creates a problem: a great Pettersson season makes him more valuable but also harder to decide about; another poor season may force Vancouver to act when his trade value is low.

This article first appeared on NHL Trade Talk and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!