Who Should Captain The Blues Next Season?

With the St. Louis Blues likely out of a playoff spot, this offseason, some tough and important decisions have to be made surrounding the captain role. With a young core continuing to develop, the choice will help define the team’s identity moving forward.

Among the candidates, Robert Thomas and Jake Neighbours are top contenders, each bringing a different type of leadership to the ice.

Why Robert Thomas?

Thomas, 26, who is currently the team’s assistant captain, has grown into one of the Blues’ most consistent and impactful players. Since entering the league, he has steadily developed into a top-line center known for his playmaking ability. His ability to control the pace of the game and create opportunities for his teammates has made him a key piece of the team’s offense.

His connection to the franchise also plays a major role in his case. Thomas has spent his entire eight-year NHL career in St. Louis and was part of the team’s run to the Stanley Cup Finals in his rookie year. That experience, combined with the years he has invested in the organization, has earned him respect both in the locker room and among the coaching staff.

While Thomas has been the subject of trade rumors, the Blues ultimately held onto him, signaling how valuable he is to the team’s long-term plans. Keeping him in St. Louis positions him as a natural leader, given his production and familiarity with the organization.

Why Jake Neighbours?

Neighbours, 24, brings a different style of leadership that is equally compelling. He has quickly developed a reputation as a player who will stand up for his teammates and play with an edge. Not afraid to engage physically or respond in scrums, Neighbours brings energy and accountability to the lineup, qualities that often define strong locker room leaders.

His influence goes beyond statistics. His willingness to defend teammates and consistently set a tone on the ice helps build trust within the team. That kind of captain-like presence, combined with his passion and intensity, makes him a serious candidate despite his youth.

The age difference between the two is minimal, and with such a young roster, choosing a captain based solely on seniority makes little sense. Both players are experienced, respected, and embody qualities the Blues value in a leader.

Big Decision Ahead

Ultimately, the decision may come down to the type of leadership the Blues want to emphasize. Thomas brings stability, elite production, and experience within the franchise. Neighbours offers intensity, grit, and a vocal presence that can energize the team in crucial moments.

Both would make extraordinary captains, and the choice may reflect the kind of culture the Blues hope to cultivate as they continue to grow and compete at the highest level.

• Jake Neighbours Leaves Game With Injury
• What’s Next for Robert Thomas Heading Into the Offseason?
• Montreal Canadiens Linked to Robert Thomas
• Robert Thomas is the Perfect Target for the Red Wings
• What Are the Best Chances for Robert Thomas Before the Trade Deadline?